What's been your worst 'Did i play the same game' moment?

[WeirdNeville]

Saints Row 2. I just hate it. It makes me feel cheap to play it, and the mechanics are so sloppy. It's like "National Lampoons GTAIV" without any jokes or budget.

Oh, and Halo3. I bought it alongside my 360, and played it first. I sat there asking myself "The developers of this are aware of Half-Life 2, right?". Ditched it and got stuck into Forza2 instead. Win.

 

[Wayne Insane]

To answer the actuual question, my worst "Did I play the same Game" moment was The first half of Dead Space.I mean that Game was pretty much the gameplay of Resident Evil 4, the story of system shock and the look of Doom 3(except for the pentagrams and shit).I really didn't like that Game.
But it's starts to happen all the time.While playing Mass Effect I thought "wow, this is KOTOR if KOTOR had bad shooter elements".
Assasins Creed had me thinking back to the good old days of Sands of Time and Thief and how much better those Games were.
And Bioshock?Just a dumbed down under the sea version of System Shock 2.
I mean, none of those newer Games really is bad(except maybe Dead Space, I really hated that)
but it seems like I've always been there before.Maybe I'm just too old to be really amzed by a new Game.But then, I really liked Fallout 3.I played the other ones years ago and loved em, but the third one takes the cake for me.