Id say that Top 5 with Lisa Foiles isnt my favourite series on the escapist, but i do watch it occasionally. Personally their argument falls apart after about first 5 seconds, they have no solid criticism apart from "Blahblahblah I dont like her stuff blahblahblah She disrepects real gamers blahblah shes just fanservice"
Ill agree there is a lot of fanservice in there, but there is no denying that she is a gamer, these guys sound like the people who treat gaming as an exclusive club. If you could measure how much of a gamer someone is then from what ive seen Lisa Is more of a gaming than most of the people I know, but you cant measure someones "gamerness" so its pointless.
I think that at least her lists are somewhat creative, so she gets points for that at least, and i do get a chuckle every now and then, i also do find out some interesting things about games or see a part that might get me interested in a game.
These guys just take themselves just a little too seriously, and they should probably grow up a little