Who did it?

[Damien the Pigeon]

You should actually give us a setup and clues and turn this into a real game. That might be pretty fun....

 

[Bofus Teefus]

LIES!! you stabbed him with the lighsaber ,before eating him!!!

Really? Oh really? Really? Allow me to present the 36th post, which we shall call Exhibit #36:

AHH I'M THE KILLER !

I DID IT !

Clearly, we have identified the killer, and it is not I. I'm off to perform miracles and whatnot now, and will leave you to swim in the falseness of your accusation.

 

[NotAPie]

^Jesus changed the realilty!
IT WAS REALLY HIM!
he is spy!

 

[Archaon6044]

it was the downtrodden, less well-off nephew who wasn't going to inherit anything, with a candle-stick in the parlour.

 

[Onyx Oblivion]

Old Man Smithers

 

[garfoldsomeoneelse]

It was Zapp Rowsdower!!!!!


.....Sorry, I never get an opportunity to use that name. Cookie to anyone who knows what movie he's from.

So, Rowsdower... it that a stupid name?

 

[Zombie_Fish]

Homer Simpson. He likes donuts and it looks like your friend was eaten.

 

[paladinkratos]

It was "No avatar"-guy.
That guy is shifty :/

you are one to talk

 

[internutt]

Cannibalism is a terrible thing. Especially between doughnuts.

 

[CriticallyAcclaimed]

There was never any donut. The donut is a lie.

 

[Shadowlolz]

OJ......... wait its about donuts.. well it was probably me since i ate 2 donuts today for breakfast mwahahahah

 

[Ultimathul]

OJ......... wait its about donuts.. well it was probably me since i ate 2 donuts today for breakfast mwahahahah

You....Sick....Bastard!

 

[Sindre1]

It was "No avatar"-guy.
That guy is shifty :/

you are one to talk

OH GOD!
He is everywhere! :O

 

[GodsOneMistake]

Jesus Christ it must of been the cupcakes

 

[KamachoMcSagget]

IT WAS YOU, except it wasnt you it was you're alternate personality that awakens when you're asleap. (whoever guesses what movie I'm refering to is awesome)

 

[Eiseman]

Guys, the butler's getting away!

Spoiler: After him!

Crap!

 

[paladinkratos]

It was me! I eat the donut because you never talk to me in Xbox Live Parties.

yes i do dylan its just you never respond to me talking and how could you do that to a poor jelly donut.

 

[EeveeElectro]

I don't like doughnuts.

I don't like anything like that actually. Chocolate cake, cookies or muffins.

Yet I'm still fat.

Life's a *****. I'm going to bed.