I've decided to restrict it to real people, since otherwise it would get way too long.
-Edward Norton
-Clive Owen
-Liam Neeson
-Samuel L. Jackson
-Sean Connery
-Johnny Depp
-John C. McGinley
-Hugh Jackman
-Morgan Freeman
-David Hayter
-James Earl Jones
-Stephen Fry
-Heath Ledger
-Will Smith
This is a list of all the (real) men that make me tingly in my pants.
...
In a totally not gay way.
-Edward Norton
-Clive Owen
-Liam Neeson
-Samuel L. Jackson
-Sean Connery
-Johnny Depp
-John C. McGinley
-Hugh Jackman
-Morgan Freeman
-David Hayter
-James Earl Jones
-Stephen Fry
-Heath Ledger
-Will Smith
This is a list of all the (real) men that make me tingly in my pants.
...
In a totally not gay way.