spookydom said:
Well, I know for a fact that my ancestor is my ancestor. We have always known. Big family scandel and also a well documented family history in public records. How can you discount everybody elses? Though in my case this leads back over a over only one hundred years. That makes it a lot simpler to check out.
Of course i'm overgeneralizing in some cases
here are the reasons why i'm doubting the validity of the rest:
1. experience on the scienfific matter (although it was only a subdiscipline in my university education, i'm well aware of the strict criteria on objectivity if you're doing genealogical research)
2. experience with people (yeah i'm getting old

)
3. closely linked with number 2:
It's the internet!
I mean come on, if people claim they are a direct descendant of Captain James Sparrow or whatever, you probably know the outcome. If genealogical research wasn't such a tedious matter, it would be no problem to proof the validity of all the assertions... But as it stands i have to settle myself for a guess...