LWS666 said:
so, i've been trying to figure htis out for a while about why people think the mass effect trilogy and dragon age 1 were such great games. whennever i think about them i think they have bad locations that don't feel as epic as they're trying to be made out, an impenetrable story with many, many plot holes, bad writing where alot of the background is in the pause menu rather than weaved into the story, akward conversation options and bland, boring gameplay.
i understand that everyone is entitled to their own opinion and if you enjoyed all of biowares games then good for you, but it seems EVERYONE thinks bioware is one of the greatest game makers of all time
#1. Not everyone enjoyed them. I see plenty of people saying they downright hated them
#2. No examples, no credit.
#3. I'll give you points on SOME of the conversation options being awkward.
I actually think the plot of Mass Effect, including the lore and the backstory of many of the characters is actually very deep and has some interesting ideas behind it. I love Drew Karpyshyn's writing so maybe that biases me a tad. The First Contact War and Humanity's quick rise on the galactic scale and how it bothers other races so much is a pretty interesting concept. However, it is all secondary knowledge to the main plotline. The things that people really need to know are presented to them in the dialogue or through how the story unfolds. Even things such as the First Contact War that I mentioned before are learned of through conversation.
Dragon Age has some growing to do but the universe that Bioware has built has an incredibly interesting take on magic and how those who use it should be treated. Most games you have some mage with all this power and they just run around without anyone saying a word. Not in Dragon Age. The whole idea of Mages being a danger to those around them, and the fact that the measures being taken to keep them safe from harm, as well as harming others, is filled with moral grey's the likes of which I really have not seen.
As for characters, Bioware is perhaps one of the greatest developers out there for characterization. Even the characters that aren't their best have interesting character flaws and traits that make them seem like real people (even if their aliens.) Garrus from Mass Effect is one of my favourites. When you first meet him, he is trying to help you, but he also resents the amount of restrictions placed on him by Citadel Security. When he comes along with you he enjoys the time he spends on the mission because he enjoys being free of the Citadel's red tape. In Mass Effect 2 we learn that the same personality he has may have gotten a dozen men killed. He learns his mistake....and keeps on making it. He's a person (maybe not human, but close with that line of thinking...) and he is prone to mistakes. He is loyal and will fight to the end for anything he believes in, but he's also a bit of a renegade.
Bioware has been making games for a longtime, they had one of the biggest plot twists in a story I had ever seen in Knights of the Old Republic, they've made some of the most recognizable characters in gaming history like Minsc from Baulders Gate ("Go for the eyes Boo!") and HK-47 from KoToR and Garrus from Mass Effect.
I love Bioware and just about every game they've made, but I love them for a reason. Not everyone feels the same way, but everyone is entitled to their opinion. We can all enjoy different games, there's thousands upon thousands to choose from after all!