Bretty said:
Over opinionated much?
I played EQ, but EQ didn't exactly bring the numbers that WoW did, even the first year of WoW saw more players on at a time than EQ ever had. Blizzard make great games, well polished, story driven (well used to) EQ was a horrible looking really really large time sink. WoW looked great, great story, and actually fun.
I played EQ for two years and WoW since Second Closed Beta. I know MMOs, I have played all of them (minus the free ones).
So, for me, WoW was the watershed in MMOs. You talk about the TV ads but WoW wasn't even on TV until the game had been out for 3-4 years? WoW did a lot right... but you seem so hugely biased to actually see it. You state things as fact when they are nothing but opninion, makes you come off as an ass. WoW became so popular BECAUSE IT WAS GOOD, as more people go to an MMO more people follow. You make it sound like people only play it because it is their and people are playing it, which is a stupid assertion.
WoW did nothing new to be labeled as you labeled. No other game like it? Like I said man, every other game was like it except a few stragglers like FFXI - and it really shouldn't be classified as breaking boundaries. Congrats for playing all the P2P MMOs. Do you know how many are out there? That means you are either lying to sound like you have final say in an MMO arguement or you are telling the truth meaning you wouldn't have time to give a full review of any of them. I don't believe you.
I see you claiming WoW as some revolutionary MMO when it did nothing revolutionary. Guild Wars tried stepping out of the box with instanced zones, a feeling of "campaigns", charactor rebuilding on the fly, no "best setup", no grind, etc. To me, that was polishing the MMO experience. Taking all the stuff alot of MMO players complain about and buffing it out. WoW made the same old content more accessible easier than Everquest did. Sped up the content basically. They "dumbed down" alot of the same ideas as other MMOs of the time. After that this was called polish.
The commercials came out after just shy of 3 years old. The point I am making about the television is it brought in new people. My own mother(53) is probably the best example when she thought she should try it out. I have tried to get my mom to play a few games like Halo and she can't do it and gets frustrated. She has a hard time playing the Sims and that is a game that is all her own interest. She has a problem grasping the controls and concepts behind games even with severe interest. Why did she feel compelled to try this MMO out? Because it is everywhere. Her very reason that she told me is because she saw it everywhere. Heard about it everywhere. WoW is shoved down your damn throat even if you are not a gamer. My grandmother(76) has inquired about it and she hates video games. So if I am a gamer and I don't like the game and think it is not good or revolutionary, yes I am a little irritated by the thing. Imagine if a title you thought was just "ok-but not that good" was being praised as "teh best game evar" and being shoved down your throat. People that hate WoW are vocal to make sure everyone can hear them over the game's ego it hasn't earned.
For you to dismiss the media shows a heavy bias on your own end. It is not that awesome... it isn't even next door to awesome. It lives in the neighborhood of "meh" but has a very large ego is all. Playing with friends in a game is fun and the lack of co-op games out there can taint one's view of how good a game actually is. Right now on consoles there is a huge outcry for Co-op games where people are even saying they would be willing to play sub-par games for co-op experiences.
"EQ was a horrible looking really really large time sink."
Ironically, this is exactly what I see WoW as. That is why I was playing Anarchy Online when WoW released. I was aware it was a cool looking really really large time sink. Is WoW better than Everquest? I guess, I didn't care much for Everquest either. That is like saying that the new Superman game is better than Superman64. (Since you spend all your time playing strictly MMOs I will take a stab and hope you are aware of that meme.) Basically, that this poo doesn't smell as bad as that poo to me.