It really depends on other factors. As long as the rest of the game isn't horrible, then yeah, most likely.
One of my favourite games is Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines. It had some severe issues with bugs, and the combat was a little clunky, but the story and the immersion really made up for it.
On the other hand, I've tried repeatedly to get into System Shock without success due to the clunky controls. No matter how much I become engrossed by the storyline, the controls always manage to remove me from the immersion the game sets up. I loved System Shock 2 though.