I'm actually pretty happy with Attack of the Show and X-play. Attack of the Show is basically the same thing, but somehow it seems better, probably because Olivia Munn is gone. I couldn't ever stand her, she was so fake it pissed me off. X-Play seems like it's grown up a little bit, drifting away from the little skits and showing what some people want "previews, reviews, MMO report, and exclusive game footage". X-Play keeps what the show was meant to be, reviews of games and added some new content that appeals to a gamer audience and not a child audience. Kudos to you G4.
On the Cops and Cheaters note, I want these off the air as much as everyone else. Give me more shows that have to do with tech or anything nerdy. Bring back reruns of Code Monkeys, for the love of god just take off the 7 hour block of Cheaters.