Karutomaru said:
Even looking at the facts it's a better game, with a more consistent framerate, longer game length, and more extras.
So we're talking about facts now rather than opinions.Ok let's examine those "facts" you mentioned
Longer game length - Longer does not equal better.You only have to look at something like Portal which is very short and yet is regarded as one of the best games ever.I would say that Overkill is the perfect length as games of that genre tend to be pretty repetitive.What matters most for games of that kind is re-playability and Overkill definitely has that.
More consistent framerate - What exactly is your evidence for this?I've beaten Overkill about a half dozen times at least and can't recall a single moment in the game where there were framerate issues
More extras - I'll admit I've never counted the number of extras in both games but Overkill is hardly a slouch in the extras and unlockables department.Anyway more does not mean better.If you have 2 buckets of shit and I've got 1 does that mean your shit is better than mine because there's more of it?
And to touch on your earlier points
Best graphics on Wii - Opinion not fact.I would contend that Nintendo's first party games have the best graphics on Wii.And again better graphics does not mean better game.For example the Bit.Trip games have simplistic 8 bit graphics and yet are amongst the best games on Wii in my opinion
Better story - Again opinion not fact.I'll take Overkills cheesy OTT B-movie story over Darksides po-faced seriousness any day just like I would prefer to watch Sam Raimi's Evil Dead trilogy over George A.Romero's more serious Dead trilogy
Provides an extra story to the RE mythos - Only relevant if you're a Resi fan which I'm not
It's my "opinion" that Overkill is the better game and guess what.It has a higher Critic and User score on Metacritic(78 and 9.0 vs 75 and 8.1)so I guess I'm not the only one who thinks that
As I said before if you think Darkside is the best game on Wii then great but please do not try to push your "opinion" as "fact"