Another vote for Nethack, wasted a lot of time on that game in school.
Yume Nikki is another good one, kind of like LSD for the PS1. It's a horror game, but it doesn't try to startle you. All it does is put you in a world of vaguely absurd, surreal rooms and lets you explore.
Embric of Wulfhammer's Castle is a favorite of mine as well. While it was made in RPG maker and looks/sounds like a classic SNES game, it's more like a visual novel where you can actually control your character. Specifically, you play as the princess of the kingdom, and pretty much every female character is more than a little gay for you. Features multiple endings, tons of branching plot paths, some good writing and humor, etc. Also slightly NSFW, but absolutely not porn.
Yume Nikki is another good one, kind of like LSD for the PS1. It's a horror game, but it doesn't try to startle you. All it does is put you in a world of vaguely absurd, surreal rooms and lets you explore.
Embric of Wulfhammer's Castle is a favorite of mine as well. While it was made in RPG maker and looks/sounds like a classic SNES game, it's more like a visual novel where you can actually control your character. Specifically, you play as the princess of the kingdom, and pretty much every female character is more than a little gay for you. Features multiple endings, tons of branching plot paths, some good writing and humor, etc. Also slightly NSFW, but absolutely not porn.