I own about 10 games on Steam I haven't installed yet and probably never will.
I honestly believe that Twilight Princess is better than Ocarina of Time, and every time I bring this up, I get told that my opinion is wrong from people whose glasses are more rosy than the garden in the White House. Well, excuuuuuuuse me, Princess, but I didn't play it back when it was new, so how do you expect me to judge it by the standards of back then, or claim that it shouldn't be judged by today's standards? Unskippable exposition dumps that say things we already know were just as annoying then as they are now, too!
[/rant]
In fact, I don't have any gaming nostalgia at all. Even Lego Racers, the first game I ever played, doesn't evoke any feelings of 'Hey, I remember this!', partly because I can't run it any more, it's so old.
My first actual game for an actual gaming platform was licensed. And it sucked.
I re-bought Mario Kart Wii a few months after I traded it in.
Edit: No Minecraft, and I don't ever intend to buy it, simply because I refuse to give into the hype, even if Extra Credits says it's good. Same thing goes for Recettear, without the bit about EC.