Hmmmm.... probably this:
1.) Psychonauts (Ps2) Excellent story, fun characters with their own distinct personalities
2.) Resident Evil 2 (PSOne)/ Silent Hill 2 (PS2)- Resi 2 reminds me of the old George Romero movies my dad used to watch with his buddies when I was very young, they even let me watch them with them, even though I was only 3 or 4 at the time. Silent Hill 2 because of it's wonderful story, a character you can relate to, and for being genuinley unsettling and scary, especially if you play it without the lights on
3.) Killzone 2 (PS3)- I am not a big fan of shooters, but I found this game fun.
4.) Persona 4 (PS2)- Love the story, love the characters, I also find this game quite addictive
5.) Deadly Premonition (Xbox 360)- Love the story, and FBI special agent Francis York Morgan has established a place in my heart as one of my favourite videogame characters.
When I mentioned how much I like Deadly premonition to a friend he gave out this incredulous squalk, but I absolutely love the story, which I value quite highly. The only reason I don't have Deadly premonition is because I don't own an Xbox 360, and I wouldn't get it just for one game, but when I stayed at a friend for 3 weeks, I played it to completion and loved every minute of it.
I know I have two games at the number 2 spot, but I love both the same and they each have their own merits (please don't make me choose

)