Dear Yahtzee..
About the Skillshots that you didn't understand:
1. News bot: Remember mission 1? when you need to headshot a reporter? yeah, the good general don't like reporters, news, and even less paper boy(bots)s... yes, i realize that this is piss sorry reason to justify why the good general wants his solders killing news bots (500 points by the way, that's a lot! you get that when you unlock a new skillshot!) but here is the answer, it's cheezy, but it IS somewhat buy-able.
2. Bugs/plants: ok, the soldiers were sent down to clean out the thugs/cults/mutants, and yes, anything that would endanger this planet to be re-populated by rich folks, and that includes the "electric flies" have you kick a thug in to a group of that? yep, it's pretty deadly, I'm sure that our good general won't like to see the sponsors' costumers' kids getting "Fly Guy" now do we? no need to explain the "man-eaters" they are... well... man-eaters, yeah, general wants that out as well...
3. Booz: notice how some bad guys, and enviroments in this game will make your screen, and movements go "shit mode"? yeh, to show to the good general that you are a solider that can work "under stress" will gain you MORE re-supply! it actually make sense! look, the Booz, basically a joke, that Grayson was a drunker, and out of his alcohol addiction, he found a way to cheat the system, he gets intoxicated with booz, so he can get extra points, to gimp more supplies! Remember act 1? where he was drunk, and he still shot the glass bottle off the bounty hunter's head? (story wise) Gray was a sharp shooter, even when is drunk! and that skill shot just reinforced that part of the plot, where he drunk himself to cheat the system, which "shouldn't" effect his performance, and if a player got killed because he was drunk, then that would mean the player was not "Grayson" enough.
By the way, I am really tire to hear you talk about how the graphic(art style) don't fit your "taste", to me, there is NO big armor on Grayson, nor his sidekick Cranky the Japanese robot... compare to duds from GOW, Grayson is almost skimpy! And just because you lack the skill to use the cannonball charge shot, doesn't make it a bad design, there is a reason why this game puts that weapon's charge shot later, you are supposed to get better at it. The whole thing about spray out enemies, was to actually make this game a worthy challenge! otherwise your review would have gone the other way saying "...the AI were so stupid moving like herds of sheep all I had to do was run around them round them up like a overarmed collie, and..." I think this game is a "forward" even in story, simple, funny, got a point, and voice acting was fine (compared to GOW or UT3).