I know, it's pretty impossible to like Other M unless you're compatible with the unusual controls, but it still saddens me to see it listed as worse than BioShock 2.
I mean... it's not that BioShock 2 is terrible either, but I took a break from it to play something else and just haven't been arsed to pick it back up. It's not a very engaging game.
Anyway, yeah, I love Other M. The story is a mess, the voice direction for Samus is abysmal, the idea that a CO would hold back heat shielding from you when you're about to enter an area only slightly chillier than Hell is dumb, and the PTSD scene really would have worked better in Super Metroid... but I just loved the gameplay enough that those issues became irrelevant. It's a terrible shame that the story and its execution couldn't have been better, yes, but not game-killing.
The whole franchise might be in need of a reboot, though.