Yahtzee Croshaw said:
Your motion sensor could have full one-to-one control and incorporate a 22-function Swiss Army Knife, but that won't change the fact that without physical feedback, motion controls are unimmersive.
Yahtzee, dear friend, I redirect you to the FPS 3rd Space Gaming Vest [http://www.thinkgeek.com/computing/accessories/b9de/].
I'll admit, the jacket doesn't sound extremely convincing. And it's not even designed for the Wii/Natal. But it's a start. Sort of like how the original Wii controllers were a "start" towards actually doing what they were designed to do. In another couple of years, I can see this physical feed back as getting better. And though the jacket alone looks goofy, if you combined Project Natal, the jacket mentioned above, and some Video Goggles [http://www.thinkgeek.com/computing/accessories/98d3/], then stood in a room, alone... It actually could be pretty damn immersive.
I think the only
real problem with the above mentioned getup, is, well... Humans aren't designed to just stand in one place. We're designed to either sit, lay down, or be moving. "Just standing" means you get eaten, and you're tiring your legs while you wait.
Those industrious game designers will figure something out, though. Oh, wait. They have. Meet the Omni-Directional treadmill:
As for the rest of the video: Great job. I know it's a good episode of ZP when I have to rewind the video because I couldn't hear part of it over my laughter.
EDIT: Related to my above info on "immersion"... I really want to get some money together to try all that stuff out. Get a copy of some Wii shooter, buy that expensive jacket, and hijack one of the military's ODTs (As I read up on ODTs, I found out that the military made the first. And it sounds like they make most of them.)