Oh I don't mind them blasting the list, most of the criticism has been fair anyway. I think for the most part I failed to communicate that a single one of those things doesn't necessarily mean the game will be bad, but the more that apply, the more likely that it will suck.axlryder said:
The Batman games are fantastic, but they don't fill many of the criteria at all, whereas pretty much the entire list applies to Aliens and Star Trek. Batman showed gameplay, Aliens showed us nothing but cutscenes and half second clips, and also allowed it to release 3 days early (in Oz) about 4 days before the review embargo lifted.