30 US Troops killed by Taliban in single attack.

[MeatMachine]

What's your take?

This wouldn't have happened if they hadn't been there in the first place.

The US puts it's nose in everyone's business and then cries foul when they get punched in the face.

Yeah, America should be ashamed of itself for going after the people who murdered thousands of civilians...

 

[Crazycat690]

I don't feel any more sympathy for the US troopers than I feel for the Talibans when death occur, as I see it both sides got there by their own will, so they could have killed themselves and I wouldn't care anymore. Actually if 30 people killed themselves at the same time that would be interesting news, people who went to war by their own will and dies don't interest me one bit. The only thing sad about it is that the US troops seem to believe they are the star in their own personal war movie.

 

[Shock and Awe]

I don't believe they've figured if it was enemy action or an accident yet. Either way though, over 20s Special Operations troops and a chopper crew, not a good day for socom.

 

[cryogeist]

First thing that came to mind was "Damn. That must have been a big helicopter!"

chinooks are huge dude
and those are the things that you could strap a artillery gun on

 

[Crazycat690]

I'm really disgusted by this. Not by the story itself, that is quite tragic. I'm disgusted by the people commenting. Saying "It's war" and "They're soldiers they deserve it" is probably some of the most disrespectful thing you can say. When someone you know dies don't come crying to us.

Can't speak for everyone but I've never done that, and I don't intend to. That would actually be a weird thing to do IMO. And then I mean the whole "When someone you know dies don't come crying to us.", because I did indeed disrespect the US soldiers, why should I feel sorry for them? I didn't ask them to fight.

 

[Gaiseric]

I'm really disgusted by this. Not by the story itself, that is quite tragic. I'm disgusted by the people commenting. Saying "It's war" and "They're soldiers they deserve it" is probably some of the most disrespectful thing you can say. When someone you know dies don't come crying to us.

Agreed. Especially considering I got a buddy in the Army, another going into the Navy, and I'm joining when I can get into good enough shape.

 

[HigherTomorrow]

What's your take?

This wouldn't have happened if they hadn't been there in the first place.

The US puts it's nose in everyone's business and then cries foul when they get punched in the face.

>implying that it's the dead soldier's fault they were deployed to Afghanistan

 

[RagTagBand]

It's war, people die, not exactly a surprise and considering these stories have been commonplace for the last decade this isn't even new.

Great news for conspiracy theorists though.

 

[Liberaliter]

At the risk of sounding incredibly insensitive Oslo was worse. Not only were there more, they were all innocents. Military combatants losing lives in a known combat zone due to the actions of enemy forces is less of a tragedy more of an occupational hazard.
Premature death is always a sad thing, but this isn't exactly shocking, surprising, or even really news.

It's not a competition, a death is a death no matter the number of how innocent they are.

 

[Richardplex]

The battle of Stalingrad in aprticular where over 2.000.000 soldiers died.

Over 2 soldiers!

*ahem*
in North America, 2,000,000=two million.
in Europe, 2.000.000=two million.

getting used to 1,95? meaning one euro ninety-five cents took a little while when I was stationed over there, but...

Apart from in England, because we are stubborn bastards very traditional and don't change what doesn't need to be changed *adjusts monocle, sips earl grey, sticks middle finger up at Euro*

OT: I'm not going to mourn the death of people who are being paid to kill people. Especially when people are saying 30 people is a huge amount. It's pretty significant, but in war, it is pretty small, especially considering civilian casualties.
However, one civilian did die, so I offer my feelings on that casualty: =(

 

[HigherTomorrow]

I don't feel any more sympathy for the US troopers than I feel for the Talibans when death occur, as I see it both sides got there by their own will, so they could have killed themselves and I wouldn't care anymore. Actually if 30 people killed themselves at the same time that would be interesting news, people who went to war by their own will and dies don't interest me one bit. The only thing sad about it is that the US troops seem to believe they are the star in their own personal war movie.

News is not entertainment.

 

[Kargathia]

That's the bloody truth of war folks, people die.

Yeah, but usually not in this large a number.

Actually, that's sort of depending on your perspective. When looking more than two months back it's more akin to "usually they don't die in these small numbers".

 

[Shock and Awe]

That's the bloody truth of war folks, people die.

Yeah, but usually not in this large a number.

Actually, that's sort of depending on your perspective. When looking more than two months back it's more akin to "usually they don't die in these small numbers".

Well for the US military incidents this large haven't happened regularly since Vietnam.

 

[Bihac]

This article implies it was coincidence, as the SEAL group was being sent in or extracted from a raid. It also states that it wasn't the same personnel, but the same unit.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/06/31-american-troops-killed_n_920063.html?icid=maing-grid7|aim|dl1|sec1_lnk3|84253

 

[Torrasque]

I'll say what I said on thedailywhat's post:

M-M-M-MONSTER KILL!

On a serious side: of COURSE the forces involved in Osama's OP were killed.
Related: theories that Osama is still alive, rise by 300% in the last 100 minutes.

 

[Crazycat690]

I don't feel any more sympathy for the US troopers than I feel for the Talibans when death occur, as I see it both sides got there by their own will, so they could have killed themselves and I wouldn't care anymore. Actually if 30 people killed themselves at the same time that would be interesting news, people who went to war by their own will and dies don't interest me one bit. The only thing sad about it is that the US troops seem to believe they are the star in their own personal war movie.

News is not entertainment.

Oh no? I'm willing to bet to you that people will buy the newspaper that says "30 US troops died in Taliban attack" any day over one that says "The political effects of the Chinese market", why? That's booring. Death and destruction catches the attention of the people, while booring political news don't entertain people.

 

[retyopy]

Right. 30 dead. Because that's so much more important than the fact that over 1500 Iraqi citizens, completely innocent, have been killed, often with just as many people as this being gunned down. It's sad, but other things need more attention. I may sound callous. That's because I am. When the world stops its downward descent to hell, I'll soften up.

 

[The Ouroboros of Red]

That's awful. I'm not going to try to say anything "deep" about war or death, or try and belittle the loss of life, so I'll just leave it at that.

 

[Karathos]

The only thing sad about it is that the US troops seem to believe they are the star in their own personal war movie.

I would love to know where you picked up this little fact from. Admittedly I'm from Finland and not the US, but I've spoken to many a US, British and Finnish soldier stationed (formerly, in some cases) in Afghanistan and none of them have talked like they think it's war movie. So either you're quoting someone else's insult to soldiers in order to seem clever, or you're just a bit ignorant to the reality of the situation. Either way, think before you write eh? Stuff like that just makes you look like an ass.

More on-topic: It's a war-zone and people will die - and people do die, daily. As a Corporal myself, I'm never happy when I read about troops get killed like this but it's what they risk when they sign up. No one forced them to go.

That's awful. I'm not going to try to say anything "deep" about war or death, or try and belittle the loss of life, so I'll just leave it at that.

One of the first intelligent posts in this thread. I salute you.