Well... I think he *is* a bit cynical... He started well enough point some good points to which I agreed... Then I think he just over-generalized... I still think there are great, deep story driven games (Alan Wake, Fable series, Heavy Rain, etc.) but there are also mindless time killers and games that fall somewhere in between... I think a lot of kids don't take much care about the story line and have their fun, which I think it's fair enough... When I was a little kid I was barely able to say "what time is it?" in English (I'm native Portuguese) and I still had tons of fun playing games that I had no idea had a story... I think that the bigger appreciation for the finer details (story, characters, music, etc.) come with age... Usually you start appreciating that stuff when you enter your teens... Either that or you turn into a Bieber fan or some shit like that.
As for his analogy that we get dead inside... I'm just 26 so I wouldn't know but I still feel pretty much alive and enjoying stuff.. I must disagree with his McDonald's analogy, though... I'm very demanding of food and I know what is a good meal but there are times where I get a whole in my stomach that only a cheeseburger can fill... Everyone I know of every age some times just wants to eat crap and it tastes like the greatest meal on earth when you eat it.
I do agree that MP feels like bullshit mostly 'cause of annoying teenagers with annoying voices making stupid insults that they think are very original and cool (they're not) and that today I just don't have that much time to play games anymore... I remember dreaming about a game like WoW but I had to terminate my account 'cause I was just wasting money... Most of my friends closed their accounts for the very same reason except for one which is currently unemployed...
I think he nailed perfectly part of the problem. The games I dreamed about when I was a kid (huge games with detailed characters, world and endless hours of gameplay) are now mostly unavailable to me. That makes me annoyed by the fucking irony of life.
I think the author must be going through some sort of a midlife crisis and this was his way of dealing with it... Nothing he said comes as a big surprise for some one that has a job and a bit of maturity... Like I said... I still pretty much enjoy games... I have a full-time office job and I'm studying... I have a ton of stuff I do on my free time (volunteer work, band practices, guitar lessons, etc.) and I still find some time to finish a couple of games I like...
Although some of his points were bullshit I generally agree with what he said...