If it's truly a personal situation among friends (as all deaths are) then those people should have gotten a personal message or an email at best a phone call not some public announcement on a forum. Honestly I consider it rude and an attempt to gather random sympathy from strangers. Sure that is not the case but that's what it appears to me. This is a private event. It should be treated as such.Urgh76 said:FriendsSwifteye said:Can we make threads about someone dying? I mean I don't want to come off as mean but what business is it of complete strangers like us to know that someone on this website is no more?
.....
that's basically it
wolfcrab said:Fuck her, you think I give a shit about a *****? I ain't a sucker
Wow, seriously guys? I would express my true feelings about people like you, but I'd probably get put on suspension for itUberaDpmn said:This is gosh-darned perfect.
Hmm, I probably should have said something more than just "friends"Swifteye said:If it's truly a personal situation among friends (as all deaths are) then those people should have gotten a personal message or an email at best a phone call not some public announcement on a forum. Honestly I consider it rude and an attempt to gather random sympathy from strangers. Sure that is not the case but that's what it appears to me. This is a private event. It should be treated as such.Urgh76 said:FriendsSwifteye said:Can we make threads about someone dying? I mean I don't want to come off as mean but what business is it of complete strangers like us to know that someone on this website is no more?
.....
that's basically it
Yes, they would love this. They would love to make their mothers cry, they would love to leave their friends as mourners and they would love to see everyone who has ever loved them grieve.easternflame said:No. We all die. We can't cry. It's selfish. How? That person is in a better place. Wether you're religious or not (like me) you know it. We hold on to people because WE won't see them again. That's the only reason. We never stop to think maybe they'd want this.Urgh76 said:
You're coming from some very good standpoints, all of them have a great foundation backing them up.Swifteye said:What value is there in the condolences of strangers? You, me, them. We are all just people. People are without value but a person is invaluable. The condolences of a person close too you could mean the whole world but what difference does it make if some passerby came and said "sorry" and just kept on with there day? Where does genuine heartfelt expression begin and kneejerk preprogrammed cultural responses end?Urgh76 said:Hmm, I probably should have said something more than just "friends"Swifteye said:If it's truly a personal situation among friends (as all deaths are) then those people should have gotten a personal message or an email at best a phone call not some public announcement on a forum. Honestly I consider it rude and an attempt to gather random sympathy from strangers. Sure that is not the case but that's what it appears to me. This is a private event. It should be treated as such.Urgh76 said:FriendsSwifteye said:Can we make threads about someone dying? I mean I don't want to come off as mean but what business is it of complete strangers like us to know that someone on this website is no more?
.....
that's basically it
To me it doesn't seem like random sympathy; it seems like it's for people to pay their respects and....... well..... yeah.
As for about why it's being brought up in the public like this......... that may actually just be a matter of opinion.
People can be friendly and just share their condolences if they want, but I just don't see sharing a death to be "rude" so long as it's not in a spiteful way.
Feelings are not some item you need to get as much of as possible to put value on a tragic event. It's a bit more complicated than that. It means actually caring and being attached. Sure you can be one of those really nice people who'd shed a tear for a lost dog if you knew someone had lost one but that just means your carelessly taking on stress and pressures of life that have nothing to do with you.
Maybe I'm just not of the ilk most people are as all these people are giving there condolences.