Album Review: Muse - The Resistance.

Recommended Videos
Oct 5, 2009
204
0
0
Now, Muse. These three lads are currently celebrating the 10th anniversary of their debut album "Showbiz". But also this year, they released their new album "The Resistance".

Don't get me wrong, I had my doubts as soon as I heard the title. The Resistance. Sounds like they've been watching too much Terminator and decided that it would be a brilliant idea to base their song titles and album name on some of the themes in that film. Although, this is a rather petty review so far.

The opening track "Uprising" is a catchy little mistress. It really will grind into your head, with it's striking resemblance to the Dr Who theme tune. Non the less, it is a great song and as the first single to be released from the album, you cannot fault it. Unless you're me, then you can fault it. But of course, there is a really nice solo in here, and if you've heard the live version, your heart will melt at the energy it causes.

The title track, "Resistance" for those who haven't caught on with the album I'm reviewing, is a strong song--Hold on a second, I just made a rhyme. It has the band singing "It could be wrong, could be wrong" which i thought was quite nice first time around, but after a while it gets quite annoying. And for some reason, whenever I listen to this song, the opening makes me daydream about the video to their song "Bliss". If you haven't seen it, go watch it to get my drift.

It seems that Muse took a lot of influence from bands like Queen and Depeche Mode, which is even more apparent on tracks like "United States of Eurasia" and "Undisclosed Desires". United States of Eurasia is Queen. Seriously, if you've never heard Queen before (god forbid) and you put this song on, you'd be like wow, that's really neat and stuff. Then you'd put Bohemian Rhapsody on and be like, "hang on a minute, I just listened to this song ... what is this bull?". And for those of you who didn't know, the piano outro, "Collateral Damage", is a piece composed by Chopin. Nocturne Op. 9 No.2. I think.

My favorite track on the album has to be "Unnatural Selection", it reminds me so much of "New Born". How I miss them days ... sorry, nostalgia caught up with me there. It has the thumping guitar riff that everyone expects from Mr. Bellamy and oh hang on, I have gotten to a part of the song and yep, I'm bored of it. Seriously, It's my favorite song on the album and I get bored half way through it. Also, I have just noticed I lied. "Undisclosed Desires" is actually my favorite song on the album but ... shut up.

MK Ultra, was a government experiment if I remember rightly. Bellamy based a lot of the songs on the album on conspiracies and of course, resisting. I actually really like this song, it has a guitar intro which sounds like a keyboard and has some crunchy riff-age later on in the song, with some nice falsetto vocals which are in my opinion Bellamy's signature aspect to his musical style. But once again, I found the song rather tedious after the 10th listen. Don't get me wrong, it's good, but most the songs do become tiresome, unlike say golden oldies like "Plug In Baby".

In all fairness, Muse were open to try something new and extraordinary, but hidden beneath all the synthesizers and the echo-y drums, you get a repeat of some of the songs off of Absolution. For example, "Guiding Light", if you got rid of the incredible guitar solo half way through the song, I would of thought I was listening to "Thoughts Of A Dying Atheist". At this point you may be thinking, "Chris, you sure do know a lot about Muse's back catalog" and that is because I am a Muse fan. And yes, I will hide from all the profanity that ensues in my direction for my sheer outing of being a fan of the band I am reviewing.

I fail to see why they put "I Belong To You" on the album. It's such a slow and cheesy song. When I first heard this song I thought to myself, "Why can I see this being used in a film?". Few weeks later, turns out it's being used in the new Twilight film. Hoorah. However, the French singing was really interesting, It gave the song it's credibility; its muse to put a pun in this review. I though the use of different instruments were nice, however, I do feel there are too many songs using piano on the album, which is a shame, as Bellamy is quite the guitarist and should be utilizing that instrument as much/more than the piano.

The finale of the album, the "Exogenesis Symphony". This was an extremely brave attempt. I mean that, Brave with a capital B. B for by god! Is this really a 15 minute orchestra related piece on a rock album? Yes, yes it is a 15 minute orchestra related piece on a rock album. At this point, I tend to just turn it to another song. It is a very soothing piece, but if you're like me and tend to be quite angsty and have to have something that will not put you to sleep whilst you're making a cheese and pickle sandwich, then this is not for you.

Call it what you want, but Muse are a great band, and this is no "Origin Of Symmetry", but I have to admit it, this is a brilliant album. Despite all my negativity, I do like this album. It's trying to show that as a 3 piece band, they can still create something as genius and magnificent as "The Resistance". Sure they may of nicked a lot of things from other bands, but it works so well, gels so smoothly without all the sticky excess you get when you try and use Brylcreem and it just does not come off of your hands. Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time you're at the "top ten" CD aisle in a store. "Do I want Muse's new album ... or do I want Jay-Z's new album?" Also, if you don't pick up "The Resistance" and bask in it's greatness, then you can go eat a dick roll. With extra mayonnaise.
 

Dudemeister

New member
Feb 24, 2008
1,227
0
0
Jesus Christ, that is one huge wall of text.
I really liked The Resistance too.
And congratulations on the awesomness of your Hadouken logo :D
 

Andalusa

Mad Cat Lady
Feb 25, 2008
2,734
0
0
I kind of went off Muse for a little bit, but there are some all right songs on the album.
It's not the greatest thing I've heard, it's certainly not the worst, it's something I'll happily listen to, not turn off if it came on, but it wouldn't be my first choice of what music to play.
 

QuirkyTambourine

New member
Jul 26, 2009
1,193
0
0
Origin Of Resistance said:
Cheers, it decided not to let me use tab, so it's all there in one huge lump. Sorry.
Just hit enter to set them into paragraphs. It's a bit hard to read because it's all one big wall o' text but I got through it.

Pretty good review, it's obvious that you know a great deal about the band which does help, and can hurt in some situations, when you're reviewing. Bias can skew your perceptions. One thing I'd suggest would be to elaborate more on each track, perhaps a small paragraph with bold typeset for each song name.

You could go into more detail for each track, because as it stands, it's a bit of a stream of consciousness.
 

danosaurus

New member
Mar 11, 2008
834
0
0
Origin Of Resistance said:
Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time your at the CD aisle in a store. "Do i want Muse's new album ... or do i want Jay-Z's new album?"
That's a very sweeping comment to make about 2009's musical releases, if Jay-Z and Muse are all you can quote then you need to do some serious musical expansions to your library.
2009's noteworthy releases;

Devin Townsend - Ki
Thrice - Beggars
Buckethead - Slaughterhouse on the Prairie
Porcupine Tree - The Incident
Pearl Jam - Backspacer
Prodigy - Invaders Must Die
Chevelle - Sci-fi Crimes
Collective Soul - Rabbit
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
Alexisonfire - Old Crows
Dream Theater - Black Clouds & Silver Linings
Sonic Youth - The Eternal
Placebo - Battle For The Sun
The Crystal Method - Divided By Night
NOFX - Coaster
Death Cab For Cutie - Open Door
The Chariot - Wars and Rumors of Wars

In regards the the Album in question;
Muse stopped being great after Absolution. That was their peak.
They still write extremely competent and radio-friendly music, all of them are brilliant musos too but I feel they need to start pursuing solo careers for a year or two to get their individual bearings, otherwise they're going to start stagnating.

Oh and in regards to your Queen-clone refernce; have you listened to 'Knights Of Cydonia' in comparison to 'Bohemian Rhapsody', I noticed that the structures are frighteningly similar.
 

GrinningManiac

New member
Jun 11, 2009
4,090
0
0
I loved Eurasia, dosen't sound a thing like Rhapsody.

Good review, mate, very informative to those who haven't brought it yet.

Going to see 'em in Birmingham!!
 
Oct 5, 2009
204
0
0
danosaurus said:
Origin Of Resistance said:
Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time your at the CD aisle in a store. "Do i want Muse's new album ... or do i want Jay-Z's new album?"
That's a very sweeping comment to make about 2009's musical releases, if Jay-Z and Muse are all you can quote then you need to do some serious musical expansions to your library.
2009's noteworthy releases;

Devin Townsend - Ki
Thrice - Beggars
Buckethead - Slaughterhouse on the Prairie
Porcupine Tree - The Incident
Pearl Jam - Backspacer
Prodigy - Invaders Must Die
Chevelle - Sci-fi Crimes
Collective Soul - Rabbit
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
Alexisonfire - Old Crows
Dream Theater - Black Clouds & Silver Linings
Sonic Youth - The Eternal
Placebo - Battle For The Sun
The Crystal Method - Divided By Night
NOFX - Coaster
Death Cab For Cutie - Open Door
The Chariot - Wars and Rumors of Wars

In regards the the Album in question;
Muse stopped being great after Absolution. That was their peak.
They still write extremely competent and radio-friendly music, all of them are brilliant musos too but I feel they need to start pursuing solo careers for a year or two to get their individual bearings, otherwise they're going to start stagnating.

Oh and in regards to your Queen-clone refernce; have you listened to 'Knights Of Cydonia' in comparison to 'Bohemian Rhapsody', I noticed that the structures are frighteningly similar.
Also, i was doing the CD aisle bit based on charts sales. I am aware of all those albums, in fact I may just review a few (Placebo, Alexisonfire, DCfC and maybe Prodigy).

In regards to Knights Of Cydonia. I did notice the similarities to BR. KoC is my favorite song. Good spot though.
 

MrSnugglesworth

Into the Wild Green Snuggle
Jan 15, 2009
3,232
0
0
danosaurus said:
Origin Of Resistance said:
Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time your at the CD aisle in a store. "Do i want Muse's new album ... or do i want Jay-Z's new album?"
That's a very sweeping comment to make about 2009's musical releases, if Jay-Z and Muse are all you can quote then you need to do some serious musical expansions to your library.
2009's noteworthy releases;

Devin Townsend - Ki
Thrice - Beggars
Buckethead - Slaughterhouse on the Prairie
Porcupine Tree - The Incident
Pearl Jam - Backspacer
Prodigy - Invaders Must Die
Chevelle - Sci-fi Crimes
Collective Soul - Rabbit
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
Alexisonfire - Old Crows
Dream Theater - Black Clouds & Silver Linings
Sonic Youth - The Eternal
Placebo - Battle For The Sun
The Crystal Method - Divided By Night
NOFX - Coaster
Death Cab For Cutie - Open Door
The Chariot - Wars and Rumors of Wars

In regards the the Album in question;
Muse stopped being great after Absolution. That was their peak.
They still write extremely competent and radio-friendly music, all of them are brilliant musos too but I feel they need to start pursuing solo careers for a year or two to get their individual bearings, otherwise they're going to start stagnating.

Oh and in regards to your Queen-clone refernce; have you listened to 'Knights Of Cydonia' in comparison to 'Bohemian Rhapsody', I noticed that the structures are frighteningly similar.
I've looked at your list. And I've listened to all of those bands (Besides a few) and almost none of those would be on the top 10 albums. They may be on YOUR top 10, but not a music stores. Very obscure bands you got there.
 
Oct 5, 2009
204
0
0
Well, to be honest, Prodigy and Pearl Jam's albums were in the top 10. But I was talking about now, the top 10 albums in the charts right NOW. Not these albums listed.
 

danosaurus

New member
Mar 11, 2008
834
0
0
Origin Of Resistance said:
Well, to be honest, Prodigy and Pearl Jam's albums were in the top 10. But I was talking about now, the top 10 albums in the charts right NOW. Not these albums listed.
To quote your OP.
..."Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway..."
You said 2009 as a whole, not 2009 as in the Latter part of the year.

Mrsnugglesworth said:
danosaurus said:
Origin Of Resistance said:
Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time your at the CD aisle in a store. "Do i want Muse's new album ... or do i want Jay-Z's new album?"
snip
I've looked at your list. And I've listened to all of those bands (Besides a few) and almost none of those would be on the top 10 albums. They may be on YOUR top 10, but not a music stores. Very obscure bands you got there.
My music tastes aside, I can honestly say that;
Pearl Jam
Prodigy
Collective Soul
Placebo
NOFX
Dream Theater

These albums have all been on display at my local JB Hi-Fi store (pretty much the biggest retailer of CD's on the Northern Beaches). I was being very objective with that list, although a lot of them do fall into the music I listen to, they happen to be popular bands in terms of sales as well.

Also - For the record, my Top 10 bands are far different to that list with the exception of Pearl Jam and maybe Collective Soul (circa 90's).
 

Aqualung

New member
Mar 11, 2009
2,946
0
0
First of all, kudos to the reviewer for the account name. ;p

And, while I must admit that my favourite CDs are Absolution and OoS, this one actually manages to come third for me. While I did miss a bit of the falsetto and great piano solos, I thought this to be something more. I kind of compare it to in a way, Showbiz and OoS are Muse drunk and wonderfully obnoxious; Absolution and BHaR are them sobering up; and Resistance seems quite sober. Piano is taking over, and the songs are growing in a new way.

Sure, some people whine and complain, "Oh! This sounds like Queen, this sounds too pop-ish, this is a bad direction!". But I think this album just proves that Muse is one of those great bands that keeps delivering new, albeit different, music that never decreases in value.
 
Oct 5, 2009
204
0
0
danosaurus said:
Origin Of Resistance said:
Well, to be honest, Prodigy and Pearl Jam's albums were in the top 10. But I was talking about now, the top 10 albums in the charts right NOW. Not these albums listed.
To quote your OP.
..."Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway..."
You said 2009 as a whole, not 2009 as in the Latter part of the year.

Mrsnugglesworth said:
danosaurus said:
Origin Of Resistance said:
Besides, 2009 hasn't been a brilliant year for music fans anyway. Think about it next time your at the CD aisle in a store. "Do i want Muse's new album ... or do i want Jay-Z's new album?"
snip
I've looked at your list. And I've listened to all of those bands (Besides a few) and almost none of those would be on the top 10 albums. They may be on YOUR top 10, but not a music stores. Very obscure bands you got there.
My music tastes aside, I can honestly say that;
Pearl Jam
Prodigy
Collective Soul
Placebo
NOFX
Dream Theater

These albums have all been on display at my local JB Hi-Fi store (pretty much the biggest retailer of CD's on the Northern Beaches). I was being very objective with that list, although a lot of them do fall into the music I listen to, they happen to be popular bands in terms of sales as well.

Also - For the record, my Top 10 bands are far different to that list with the exception of Pearl Jam and maybe Collective Soul (circa 90's).
Ah you got me there. Have to hand it to you.
 

Eagle Est1986

That One Guy
Nov 21, 2007
1,976
0
0
Pretty good review actually. Surprised you don't like I Belong To You, it's one of my favourite songs. Or at least it was until they were asked to rework it for whatever the next Twilight film is called.
And Resistance is another of my favourite songs, and another you don't seem to keen on.

Personally I love the overall feel of the album, it's very Nineteen Eighty Four but with more of a love story. Then Exogenesis is more futuristic, talking about how we should leave our planet and start again, I love it, especially the middle part. Really can't work out why they cut it into three parts though.
 

Novajam

New member
Apr 26, 2008
965
0
0
I think this is a pretty nice way to set up a music review, though I must say I'm a little gob-smacked that you go through most of it saying that The Resistance largely a rehash of the band's old songs, but at the end say it's worth a purchase.

Origin Of Resistance said:
Also, i have just noticed i lied. "Undisclosed Desires" is actually my favorite song on the album but ... shut up.

...

Also, if you don't pick up "The Resistance" and bask in it's greatness, then you can go eat a dick roll. With extra mayonnaise.
Advice wise, I'd say try not to be condescending toward your reader. It makes you look as if you're talking at them rather than to them (i.e. rudely) and I'm sure you can think of a better way to get your point across. You could use a extra proof read just to catch things like capital letters (I's in particular).

I didn't like the album that much myself. I can listen to it, but after a couple of songs I just want to go back to their older albums. The Resistance seems a little all over the place with a bit being what you might have expected after Black Holes and Revelations, a bit being a throwback to Absolution and Origin of Symmetry and the rest being experimental and self indulgent. Which is fine, more power to them if they're playing what they want to play. I just didn't like it as much.
 
Oct 5, 2009
204
0
0
Novajam said:
I think this is a pretty nice way to set up a music review, though I must say I'm a little gob-smacked that you go through most of it saying that The Resistance largely a rehash of the band's old songs, but at the end say it's worth a purchase.

Origin Of Resistance said:
Also, i have just noticed i lied. "Undisclosed Desires" is actually my favorite song on the album but ... shut up.

...

Also, if you don't pick up "The Resistance" and bask in it's greatness, then you can go eat a dick roll. With extra mayonnaise.
Advice wise, I'd say try not to be condescending toward your reader. It makes you look as if you're talking at them rather than to them (i.e. rudely) and I'm sure you can think of a better way to get your point across. You could use a extra proof read just to catch things like capital letters (I's in particular).

I didn't like the album that much myself. I can listen to it, but after a couple of songs I just want to go back to their older albums. The Resistance seems a little all over the place with a bit being what you might have expected after Black Holes and Revelations, a bit being a throwback to Absolution and Origin of Symmetry and the rest being experimental and self indulgent. Which is fine, more power to them if they're playing what they want to play. I just didn't like it as much.
True, it is an original piece, it's just that you can easily spot similarities between previous songs/albums.

As for the condescending remarks. If you've read my Paramore review, you'd notice I've been pretty fair and based it as a review, where as this one is more of a Yahtzee styled review.