Great list man, seeing lots of those games brought back memories, and I'd mostly agree w/ you on the ones I've played (Warcraft III, HL, starcraft, twisted metal (incidentally I'm surprised you didn't mention #4, that was my fav apart from #2, I wasn't wild a/b 1 or 3 and didn't play black), sims, and spyro.
One change I would make personally is replacing spyro (which I did love and have many fond memories of) with Croc, dunno if you ever played it but it felt kinda similar to spyro except better imho, you play as a badass lil crocodile with a backpack saving these little brown fuzzy things, don't even remember what they were called but I do remember vividly the sounds they made and stuff... good times
I would also add, maybe even at #1, crash bandicoot 2 (3 would get an honorable mention). That game was really somethin special