Amnesia: Dark Descent. Scariest game ever?

[TrogzTheTroll]

So scary, I never finished it. I had to watch a friend do it.

 

[Hader]

A simple question really, to all those who played, and Finished amnesia, was it the scariest game you ever played? Not the best game, not the most entertaining, but scariest, made you pause the game, leave the room, affect your breathing and pulse, make your pinky sore from holding down the crouch button.
opinions appreciated.

It is HILARIOUS when played with friends in the room with you. Alone, it can be really fucking scary.

I have only gotten past the parts I have been told are nothing compared to the rest (just after the elevator). So I plan on trying to finish it soon...

I have one video of me playing this so far. Nothing special at all really, however I pulled a horribly stupid move at the end of this video if anyone cares to watch

 

[MulticolorCharizard]

Fatal Frame 2 and Silent Hill 3 take the cake

 

[Hound174]

Nope.

Fatal Frame takes that prize, by a long shot.

Fatal Frame didn't scare me as much actually.
I Only played number 2, and there were moments were I was feeling suspensed, and waiting for something sart, which happened twice, But it really was incompareable to Amnesia for me. Had better atmosphere

 

[RobCoxxy]

I'm recording my own gameplay videos, to be uploaded shortly, it's a shitfest. :/

 

[Hader]

I'm recording my own gameplay videos, to be uploaded shortly, it's a shitfest. :/

Fun isn't it?

I did a livestream to my friends so they could watch me play. The results were hilarious.

 

[Nyan Cat]

I think it's scary... Although I can't play Dead Space for more than 15 minutes at a time >.>

 

[Wutaiflea]

I won't let my husband play it in the same room as me.

I'm jumpy enough as it is without freaky noises and disappearing/reappearing baddies.

 

[darth.pixie]

So has anyone tried fighting? Maybe beating a monster to death with a chair or something?

Yeah, nothing happens. It's as if you're hitting the wall, then you die.

I think I'm partly immune to scary games or movies by now. Amnesia was good and scary but not that frightning to me (never screamed, never stopped playing, finished it in one go during the night). Dead Space bored me.

The Silent Hill series was good if you get into it. The scary part about this is when I'm done with the game, saying that it could have been creepier, I imagine my own scenarios in my own house. Then, I get scared. My imagination is a horrid place to be.

 

[TheVicariousWriter]

To be honest I think Fatal frame, specifically 2, got me the most. While Amnesia had it's moments, I could still sit through them without getting jittery. after about 20 minutes to half an hour of fatal frame my friends and I had to shut it off because we began jumping at the slightest sounds we heard.

Hell the people who weren't even playing were screaming near the end of our game session. That's a pretty good game when it scares the people who aren't even playing it.

 

[Xeros]

Scariest game ever, I can't really say. However, it's damn sure the scariest game I've ever played.

 

[binvjoh]

I haven't played it, but considering watching Let's Plays of it scared me I'd say so.

 

[decaINNERdence]

amnesia: the dark descent is the most powerful laxative in existence. end of story.

 

[snagli]

I would rather eat a box full of razor blades than play that game again. i mean that in a good way, though.

 

[Zhukov]

Yes, I do believe it is.

It is significantly scarier than Silent Hill 2 or Fatal Frame 2. And it shits all over the likes of F.E.A.R., Dead Space or Condemned.

Amnesia is in a league all of its own.

 

[Tax_Document]

Fatal Frame's graphics were hilarious, they tried so hard to be scary but fell flat on it's face! It's a Japanese Horror Game, and like their movies, are so damn FUNNY!

Fatal Frame was funny, Amnesia was horrifying.