Owyn_Merrilin said:
Sturmdolch said:
I hate hearing people say, "Oh my gawd I loooooved Star Trek as a kid! I was such a GEEK!" No you weren't. If you were, you'd know that Star Wars is infinitely better than Star Trek.
No, a true geek would be able to appreciate both -- and a really serious geek would much rather watch
Star Trek: The Motion Picture than
Star Trek (2009), which was basically
Star Wars in
Star Trek clothing. Seriously,
Star Wars has cross sub-cultural appeal; it takes a true nerd to geek out over
Star Trek, but anyone who likes explosions can enjoy
Star Wars.
A "true" sci-fi geek would complain that both Star Trek and Star Wars are barely even science fiction (Star Trek is at the very, very "soft" end of the spectrum, and Star Wars is more like fantasy set in space) and then go back to the Nerd-Cave to
read instead, because there's relatively little sci-fi stuff in TV/movie form that isn't so soft it's squishy. As much fun as both of those are (and I've spent many, many hours with both and enjoy them), they're not nearly as geeky (and usually not nearly as good, in my opinion) as some of the books and short stories out there. I'm probably a bit biased by growing up with access to a pretty significant collection of books from the Golden Age, though (a lot of which I was lucky enough to be given by my uncle, who was into them when he was growing up).