traceur_ said:
You think we have no morals because we don't believe your morals, morals that were set forth by an omnipotent puppet master. We do not believe in any singular set of morals for we are without a common creed, each of us chooses our own morals. You think you are the only one wise enough to grasp what right and wrong are? "believe in some invisible moral force that everyone supposedly should adhere to. No such thing as right and wrong in that world view" what world view exactly are you referring to? As i have said each of us chooses our own morals so how can you say we don't know what right and wrong are, I don't think that each of us has given you a list of what we think is right and wrong so how can you pass judgment on our morals when you do not know what they are? You truly are a fool if you would pass judgment on me without ever having known me.
Easy tiger! I never said atheists can't have morality or morals, I'm only saying there is no basis for it. You certainly can judge for yourself what right or wrong is, but to assume that there is a universal moral framework in an amoral universe is silly.
And in a naturalist worldview, where there is no god or anything 'supernatural' (That means spiritualism is out), there is no such thing as right or wrong. It's completely subjective. You could say 'stealing is wrong' and someone else could say 'stealing is ok'. Who is wrong? Who is right? You yourself said that we judge for ourselves what right and wrong is, so what happens when opposing judgments of morality collide?
And, finally, I never passed judgment on you. I never said you, or anyone else, was immoral or evil or anything of the sort. I simply said there is no basis for morality in a naturalist worldview, and no such thing as a universal moral framework in said worldview.
i apologize for the level of aggression in the post to which you are referring, what I don't understand is this:
"You certainly can judge for yourself what right or wrong is, but to assume that there is a universal moral framework in an amoral universe is silly."
We do no not believe there is a universal moral framework, we each construct our own framework, though the materials used in that construction are in part supplied by our education, upbringing and experience, the method of construction is up to us.
When you say we have no basis for our morals, what exactly do you mean? The basis for my own utilitarian views is my desire to be practical in all my endeavors.