the_tralfalmadorian said:
Indigo Prophecy (Farenheit in Europe) Immediately comes to mind. The game is absolutely amazing up until one point where the story just goes bat shit crazy. if you've played the game, you know exactly what point i'm talking about....
Tell me about it, the game started out incredible, had this gripping story that just pulls you in, then they start with the supernatural stuff, very subtle about it though, and then it gets less subtle with it, and less, and then it's just smacking you in the face, then it's just BSI.
Anyway, on the subject, Indigo Prophecy. Game gives you all these great paths to choose, and this seemingly near unlimited amount of choice while going through the story, and then it all boils down to three endings, all of which kind of sucked. All the choices throughout the game meant nothing because you basically just choose which ending you want to see at the end of it all.
The only other big one that I can think of would be Beautiful Katamari. Good game, but for whatever reason the makers decided to leave a good chunk of it on Live for you to download, wouldn't be so bad, if not for the fact that many people don't have access to Live, and so all those levels and cousins and whatnot, can't get them.