Biggest Plot twist/revelation in a game.

[DoctorPhil]

Spoiler: Tales of Symnphonia

When Remiel slowly shows himself to be an evil prick. It often happens in JRPGs that the people at the head of a religion turn out to be evil, but the angels themselves, that was new for me. Oh and then God himself descends from heaven and kicks your ass. The writers have cleverly duped me into thinking it was a bland unoriginal story, and then they smacked my expectations in the face and gave me an awesome twisty turny story.
The many plottwists in ToS is why I consider it one of my favorite games.

 

[LilRock1976]

Braid when you find out you are actually the bad guy.

 

[Timewave Zero]

...Finding out that the Princess is in another castle.

 

[marfin_]

I'd agree kotor had the best plot twist ever!

 

[Ryu-Kage]

Your client, while he didn't commit the murder himself, DID hire the assassin who brought the victim down. He is actually GUILTY. ~ Phoenix Wright, Justice for All

^Probably not the biggest but still a neat one.

 

[Coldster]

KOTOR.

This this this, and this. That just came out of nowhere, except it didn't, it dropped clues for you. That was, in my opinion, the perfect way to do something like that.

OT: Hard to think of one... Bioshock has been taken so...

Oh! I'm not sure if this counts, but I like how in Halo the Sangheili find out about the Prophet's lies. That had to be a twist for them.

Huh, never thought about that twist from Halo. They must think its the biggest plots twist eh?

OT: Bioshock still gets my vote, nuff said right?

 

[bombadilillo]

I think Kotor takes it. Out of all revelations that one made me WTF the most. Just such a good devise/explanation. There was plenty of allusions to it before hand so it made it plausible. Well played. That is one of those things I WISH I could unknow so I could experience it again.

 

[ImprovizoR]

I think Kotor takes it. Out of all revelations that one made me WTF the most. Just such a good devise/explanation. There was plenty of allusions to it before hand so it made it plausible. Well played. That is one of those things I WISH I could unknow so I could experience it again.

KOTOR does take the crown. There's no point in dancing around it and trying to figure out what could beat that twist.

 

[bombadilillo]

I think Kotor takes it. Out of all revelations that one made me WTF the most. Just such a good devise/explanation. There was plenty of allusions to it before hand so it made it plausible. Well played. That is one of those things I WISH I could unknow so I could experience it again.

KOTOR does take the crown. There's no point in dancing around it and trying to figure out what could beat that twist.

I was trying to be awesome and original and think of something else, but damn....thats the best. Oh Star Wars, I wish I didnt watch the movies throughout childhood to get a fresh "Luke I am your father twist."

 

[ninjapenguin1414]

I know i'm gonna be the only one thinking this but in Prince of Persia Warrior Within when you find out your the sand wraith, I thought that was totally awesome!

 

[NickKuroshi0]

bioshock learning u were being controlled the whole time by the creepy atlas guy and that any one who is actually sane sounding in the game are the most crazy!!!!

 

[Harry Mason]

Silent Hill: Shattered Memories and Silent Hill 2 tie together in my mind.
They both expertly hide the truth, even at the last minute they don't let you have an easy guess.

While I was genuinely impressed and touched with 2's twist, Shattered Memories had me crying. It was, in my opinion, more impacting due to how long the twist was hidden (You find out the truth at the end). Silent Hill never fails when manipulating your emotions.

~Efrit

Holy shit. How didn't I think of SH2?!
Also, thanks for reminding me that I really, really need to plug my PS2 back in and finish Shattered Memories. And FF X. And Sphinx. And Silent Hill 4.

I'm going to have to third Silent Hill 2. Perhaps the effect has worn off by now, but going into that plot-twist blind was the single most emotional moment I've ever had because of a video game.

 

[bombadilillo]

bioshock learning u were being controlled the whole time by the creepy atlas guy and that any one who is actually sane sounding in the game are the most crazy!!!!

I wouldnt say bioshock was best twist. Its basically, your friend was really bad the whole time! Which is way overdone in games. It WAS however the best executed of that basic plot I have ever seen. The writing for that and the phrase were superb.

 

[LiquidGrape]

This might say more about myself than the actual game, but I thought Jade Empire was exceedingly successful in this area.

Spoiler: Honestly, I did *not* see that coming.

KOTOR was pretty brilliant, yes, but i'm going with Jade Empire. that whole game was a lineup of masterfully thought up, redicolously well laid out gambits. if you played it, you know exactly what i'm refering to. if not, then go and do it! now! i'm friggin serious!

Oh hey, someone agrees!

 

[Baconmaninspace]

I actually just experienced a pretty big one today!

Spoiler

Crono's death in Chrono Trigger. I just couldn't believe that the character whose name is a homophone for half the title, the character who you cannot remove from your party at any time, dies. I haven't played very far past it yet, and I know he'll probably come back at some point (seeing as it is a game about time travel, they'll be able to pull that off in a way that isn't contrived), but still, that threw me for a loop.

 

[dystopiaINC]

KOTOR was pretty brilliant, yes, but i'm going with Jade Empire. that whole game was a lineup of masterfully thought up, redicolously well laid out gambits. if you played it, you know exactly what i'm refering to. if not, then go and do it! now! i'm friggin serious!

Oh I know exactly what you're talking about, and when it happened, I was in shock. I just recently got the game again off of amazon, and I totally forgot about that twist, so when it happened, I was like O_O

yeah, this old bioware stuff kicks everythings ass, storytellingwise. anyone who played kotor for instance could not keep a straight face when calling something from assassins creed a "plot twist"

actually i could. sorry but bio ware games are good story wise, and i love me some kotor more than anything but assassins creed does have a pretty good one. still not bioware level though.

as anybody mentioned mass effect 1 where sovereign is more than just a big ship? or me2 with what their DOING to the humans...yeah chills with both of them.

 

[kidd25]

F.E.A.R 1-3 your always working for ALMA wither you know it or not and yet she is always trying to kill you, but in trying to kill her, she beats you.

 

[CODE-D]

SAMUS DOESNT HAVE A Y CHROMOSOME!!!!!! the hell...

 

[MrA]

inFAMOUS 2.

InFAMOUS 1 was good but not mind blowing where as "Oh look it's John. OHHHHH SHIITTTTTT" was just such a great experience