Bronies Get the Cracked Treatment

[Unesh52]

No one can say whether the meme will pass as these young men discover the vast superiority of human females

>Not a meme
>lots of bronies have girlfriends - sometimes they're even married to them (gasp!)

I mean, I'm not mad or anything, it's Cracked after all, but the question was whether it treated bronies fairly. And at least for that, it doesn't quite. It's better than some, but it doesn't exactly go all the way.

 

[NEREVAR117]

I was expecting some criticism or nasty hate from Cracked when I saw what was within the article, but I was pleasantly surprised with how they portrayed us.

 

[hittite]

NOTHING...I repeat...NOTHING...Can be too hard on bronies.

Even a hammer across the face isn't hard enough......

Never before has a fad pissed me off as much as My Little Pony



Now if this was a Spiderman thread..........

ok guys, this is now a spiderman thread.

Why can't it be both?

Rule #146: A Spider Man derail does not necessitate the death of a thread.

Edit: How has a pony thread gone two pages without a link to the user group?
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/groups/view/MLP-Friendship-is-Magic

 

[Berithil]

You know, the people who hate the show sometimes are just as annoying, if not more so than the over the top fans. If you don't like the show, fine. Your entitled to your opinion. But the only two types of people I've encountered online who actually hate the show are those who hate it because they close-mindingly deduct "MLP =gay" and don't give the show a chance , and the people who hate on the community for whatever reason. And I just have to say, the super fans hatred complain are, like a lot of fanbases, the minority. I'll also point out that there are very few pony threads right now. So, if you hate pony threads, just don't enter them. Also, the whole sexual fetish theory annoys and disgusts me to no end. Sure, maybe there are some who like it for that reason, but most aren't. Im getting tired of the ignorant attempt to sexualise everything.

/rant

Anywho, on topic, I'm quite surprised that the article was that tame. Knowing cracked, I would think they would rip the whole thing apart

 

[CobraX]

Cracked has good content, although the article in question was mediocre. It was alright and it was nice to see someone talking about bronies who wasn't insanely hostile towards them. Why people are so hostile against the Male MLP Fandom I'll never know.

Also Fluttershy is nothing compared to Rainbow Dash. Rainbow Dash is the best.

 

[Orks da best]

Bronies is a fandom I too, cannot stand. It's not that they like the show. I don't care less about what people like. It's how they go about justifying plastering it everywhere, like they're some bizarre kind of colourful horse-based revolutionaries. Look at us, we don't fit in with male gender stereotypes! We're rewriting the definition of manly!

Ugh. Every freakin' time. Look. It's a girl's show. If you want to watch it, go ahead and watch it. I'm not going to complain. However. Those avatars. Those gifs. You don't have them because you like them, you have them because they're My Little Pony. I personally don't like my avatar. I chose it because I had nothing else to choose from. I'd change it, but it's kind of associated with my name now, and I'd rather not confuse people. But I like Armoured Core. Kind of. I enjoyed the second game. Okay, back on track.

You don't like the show. You've become the show. While I think Trekkies take it a little bit too far sometimes, and I don't get their jokes, I can understand why you'd get into a franchise as big as that. THAT, at least, is the target audience. You guys are getting off over a story about FRIENDSHIP. I'm not sure how hard I have to hit these nails for you to understand. They are happy little horses who are struggling to understand friendship. This is morality for kids. You should not be entertained by this drivel. Good God.

Mm, I see where you're getting at but.. aren't you basing this info off like everyone else does on any other franchise? Like almost half the things you said, were based on COD fans, and the other stuff reminded me of 2.. no, three users that got tired of seeing Skyrim fans since they weren't all into it.

Most of the fans do not even brag or force their passion onto others about the show. It's only the few, very few... who go over the top. You know me, know that I am a Brony and yet I don't do anything to make you feel "Wow, this guy keeps pushing that MLP stuff on me. Not cool!" What I don't get about this website is that a lot of people state negative aspects about a subject when really it's not around enough to be brought up. Only when this thread comes up do people start saying such things because they're reminded.

If you dislike it, hate it.. I am fine with it. I don't blame you. It's not for everyone which I agree it really isn't. But, not liking it because you see people wearing Avatars and having GIFs about them? What about science fans who have SciFi Avatars? Or your Avatar that deals with Anime which most people can't stand them ether? By the way, to bring up a good point.. Lauren Faust got on the people saying it's a girls show only. Take a look:

So again, I am perfectly fine with you disliking the show but why come onto this Thread just to state how tired you are about the show itself? It's like if I went to a Skyrim thread and bashed the fans because I am merely tired of their passion over it when really it's just all in that forum, let alone we have a MLP Group that we don't spread the passion anywhere else. We're mature like that, but doesn't make you immature. Just giving you a heads up bro.

Ok go Lauren faust for stating the truth! Honesty i love the show (Rarity is the best pony naysayers) but do i care if other people like it or not, no, i just love watching the show and love the characters.

 

[Not G. Ivingname]

You thought you were safe from these topics now? You were mistaken. Some bronies just want to watch the world burn.

http://www.cracked.com/blog/the-4-most-unexpected-fan-bases-in-pop-culture/

Cracked.com released a recent article detailing "The 4 Most Unexpected Fan Bases in Pop Culture", and while I don't know anything about those other three entries, the article caught my attention with the first one...

"But when the show rebooted in 2010, it made a point of being everything previous iterations of the show lacked. Friendship Is Magic concentrated on character development, humor, conflict and, above all, providing lessons for girls on the complex nature of friendship. But all those elements accidentally perked the interest of another demographic entirely: young adult males."

I find this especially impressive considering I was catching up on my ponies just last night. Maybe if I had paid more attention to Pinkie Pie's twitching, I would've seen this article coming.

What's more eerie, is the quote they use under that picture of some grinning guy. Those picture quote-captions are something Cracked articles use frequently, but the quotes are always supposed to be hilarious and unrealistic. Yet, the truth is a lot of us would actually say something like that. I know I would. What does it say about us when an attempt at parodying our dialect is hardly a parody at all? I don't know. And I don't care. I'm still a "Fluttershy all the way."

I'm actually pretty relieved to read this entry, because it's evidence that bronies are far from gone and I was beginning to worry I jumped on the bandwagon way too late. But what do you think of it? Was it too hard on bronies, or was it just hilarious?

Note, this isn't the first time the series appeared on the site, it has been on several of the photoplasties, but never an article before.

 

[Spinhorse]

The Morrissey bit surprised. I'm latinamerican but I've only ever heard "everyday is like sunday". I had never heard of this trend before. Also, the brony part is decent- it's not the usual crap about fetishes and pedophilia and whatnot.

 

[ultrachicken]

Bronies is a fandom I too, cannot stand. It's not that they like the show. I don't care less about what people like.

You guys are getting off over a story about FRIENDSHIP. I'm not sure how hard I have to hit these nails for you to understand. They are happy little horses who are struggling to understand friendship. This is morality for kids. You should not be entertained by this drivel. Good God.

If you don't have a problem with other people liking different things, then why does it simultaneously bother you so much?

And the reason bronies are always justifying their love of the show is that almost everyone who isn't a brony is constantly demonizing them (bestiality lovers, pedophiles).

 

[AstylahAthrys]

I really hate Twilight so I don't go to places made for Twilight fans.

Wait, what? You don't like Twilight? ...Oh, that Twilight. Damn, I had nearly managed to forget it existed.

Yes, the abomination Twilight. Not the cute pony. I love Twilight Sparkle!

 

[For.I.Am.Mad]

When it comes to the bronies I can't help but to think of the old geometric rule: Every square is a rectangle but not every rectangle is a square.

Get what I'm saying?

 

[Thyunda]

Bronies is a fandom I too, cannot stand. It's not that they like the show. I don't care less about what people like. It's how they go about justifying plastering it everywhere, like they're some bizarre kind of colourful horse-based revolutionaries. Look at us, we don't fit in with male gender stereotypes! We're rewriting the definition of manly!

Ugh. Every freakin' time. Look. It's a girl's show. If you want to watch it, go ahead and watch it. I'm not going to complain. However. Those avatars. Those gifs. You don't have them because you like them, you have them because they're My Little Pony. I personally don't like my avatar. I chose it because I had nothing else to choose from. I'd change it, but it's kind of associated with my name now, and I'd rather not confuse people. But I like Armoured Core. Kind of. I enjoyed the second game. Okay, back on track.

You don't like the show. You've become the show. While I think Trekkies take it a little bit too far sometimes, and I don't get their jokes, I can understand why you'd get into a franchise as big as that. THAT, at least, is the target audience. You guys are getting off over a story about FRIENDSHIP. I'm not sure how hard I have to hit these nails for you to understand. They are happy little horses who are struggling to understand friendship. This is morality for kids. You should not be entertained by this drivel. Good God.

Mm, I see where you're getting at but.. aren't you basing this info off like everyone else does on any other franchise? Like almost half the things you said, were based on COD fans, and the other stuff reminded me of 2.. no, three users that got tired of seeing Skyrim fans since they weren't all into it.

Most of the fans do not even brag or force their passion onto others about the show. It's only the few, very few... who go over the top. You know me, know that I am a Brony and yet I don't do anything to make you feel "Wow, this guy keeps pushing that MLP stuff on me. Not cool!" What I don't get about this website is that a lot of people state negative aspects about a subject when really it's not around enough to be brought up. Only when this thread comes up do people start saying such things because they're reminded.

If you dislike it, hate it.. I am fine with it. I don't blame you. It's not for everyone which I agree it really isn't. But, not liking it because you see people wearing Avatars and having GIFs about them? What about science fans who have SciFi Avatars? Or your Avatar that deals with Anime which most people can't stand them ether? By the way, to bring up a good point.. Lauren Faust got on the people saying it's a girls show only. Take a look:

So again, I am perfectly fine with you disliking the show but why come onto this Thread just to state how tired you are about the show itself? It's like if I went to a Skyrim thread and bashed the fans because I am merely tired of their passion over it when really it's just all in that forum, let alone we have a MLP Group that we don't spread the passion anywhere else. We're mature like that, but doesn't make you immature. Just giving you a heads up bro.

No, no! That's not what I said! I have nothing against people liking the show. Yeah, I don't like it. I don't like Star Trek much either. Not only that, but Faust is telling me I'm backwards, sexist and outdated because I don't get all wet over little pink ponies? What manner of bollocks is this? I think you'll find, Faust, this opinion is not outdated, this opinion is perfectly freaking logical. Please don't tell me I'm the only guy who was brought up the old-fashioned, Scottish way? Disciplined by shoes, exercised by sibling warfare, all that stuff?

Aw, hell, I might even like the show if I watched it. God knows I've had worse. But once a freaking gain, it's not the SHOW that annoys me. It's the fans. Their lack of self awareness is actually ridiculous.

 

[Thyunda]

You guys are getting off over a story about FRIENDSHIP. I'm not sure how hard I have to hit these nails for you to understand. They are happy little horses who are struggling to understand friendship. This is morality for kids. You should not be entertained by this drivel. Good God.

Au contraire. Sometimes you have to go back to basics to fix a friendship. I'll give you just one example - everybody has that one neighbor. That one neighbor your mom doesn't like and they're passive-aggressive to each other over some tiny stupid shit that happened five years ago, probably at a get-together, probably having to do with somebody's cooking. But do they kiss and make up? NO! They stay passive-aggressive for the rest of eternity because it's too much trouble to talk things over.

Never had that. But, to be fair, my mother was not the passive aggressive sort, and my dad's from Glasgow, so neighbours this far South tend not to start anything. And for me personally, I get on with all my neighbours. I can see your point, though.

However. Ponies don't have real problems.

 

[Thyunda]

Bronies is a fandom I too, cannot stand. It's not that they like the show. I don't care less about what people like.

You guys are getting off over a story about FRIENDSHIP. I'm not sure how hard I have to hit these nails for you to understand. They are happy little horses who are struggling to understand friendship. This is morality for kids. You should not be entertained by this drivel. Good God.

If you don't have a problem with other people liking different things, then why does it simultaneously bother you so much?

And the reason bronies are always justifying their love of the show is that almost everyone who isn't a brony is constantly demonizing them (bestiality lovers, pedophiles).

The first quote of mine was a serious, verified opinion. The second quote was just me saying I don't like it, albeit in exaggerated, dramatic terms.

I don't demonise bronies. I don't think they want to have sex with the ponies, nor the girls watching the show. I just think they should shut up about it.

 

[FamoFunk]

Lauren Faust got on the people saying it's a girls show only. Take a look:

I love her. A a parent to a little Girl, I completely agree there's nothing out there, 'for Girls'. My Girl loves "Boys" shows, but She adores MLP (And so do I!) and it's about time there was something like this that is targeted for the Female side of children.


And who gives a shit is Adult Males andFemales like it? It's just a show, after all.

OP- I read this yesterday, I like the link they provided where Pinkie Pie mentioned Bronies!

 

[Macgyvercas]

As a Brony myself, I approve of the rather gentle nudging from Cracked. I've seen worse things said about Bronies.


Also, you can have Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash all the way.

Twas funny. And I'll keep on Team Fluttershy, thank you. Because she can stare down a cockatrice.

 

[Zeren]

I like the part where they claim that they cant wait for us to figure out the appeal of females. I found my girlfriend via a pony chat room. My liking of an unconventional show lead me to finding love!

 

[Ruwrak]

Well they didn't call us furies

No thankfuly not. There are already to many notions that are largely generalised right?

On topic: I think the MLP series is fascinating. If you watch it with an grown ups mind there are alot of disturbing underlying notions. Just like with the Lion King for example.

That's some dark stuff there. Not that kids would ever know.

 

[MasterOfHisOwnDomain]

I like the show because it has good animations, is immensely positive and reminds me of those 90s shows such as The Powerpuff Girls and Dexter's Laboratory that I absolutely loved. It's a case of animation quality + good content + nostalgia, and I'm happy that I watch it.