Adamantium, or Mandalorian Iron? Which is stronger? Because even a lightsaber will cut through Beskar after a while.
Can a lightsaber cut through adamantium??
- Thread starter Sam_Winchester
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Well, then I'll say that the LIGHTsabre is canon, and not the "plasma contained in a forcefield" (an equally ridiculous concept). After all, the LIGHTsabre was there first so it wins by rank of seniority.Geo Da Sponge said:
And as discussions go, im not really obliged to adhere to arguments about this saying that "George Lucas changed his mind". Because if we're gonna go with the whimiscal ideas of that man, then pretty much anything goes and will be just as valid as anything else.
Still, I resent the Star Wars franchise a lot. Then again, im not too fond of Marvel either, but at least Marvel has pretty much been the same thing since it started. Star Wars was decent (because good actors and decent scriptwriting held it afloat) but ultimately fell from grace because George Lucas got way too full of himself.
yes but good sir you fail to notivce that it is a game and when any old body gets a lightsaber that does what's originally described nothing would stay standing it was those moments of hacking up transdoshin thugs with savage metal blades and yet we had a fairly decent duel I was liek what the crap so I don't believe KotOR should qualify in this debateUltratwinkie said:
A lightsaber is made of plasma.
Applying that logic, a lightsaber can -burn- through anything given enough time. Even adamantium.
There's a difference between cutting and burning, a lightsaber doesn't "cut" in the sense of a knife, it technically burns through the victim/object with a plasma-based loop of energy.
Applying that logic, a lightsaber can -burn- through anything given enough time. Even adamantium.
There's a difference between cutting and burning, a lightsaber doesn't "cut" in the sense of a knife, it technically burns through the victim/object with a plasma-based loop of energy.
Except that, you know, you don't get to decide what's canon since you're not a significant representative of the franchise? And merely calling it a lightsabre doesn't inherently mean it's made of light. It could just be in reference to it's appearance, the fact that it glows or even the fact that it is comparatively light when compared to a regular sabre.Housebroken Lunatic said:
But come on, you really need to relax. The Star Wars franchise has pretty much collapsed under it's own weight so there's nothing really left to do with it except pick out obscure details just for the fun of meaningless arguments.
Like mister lunatic in the previous page if we are introducing reality to this arguement anything that can be melted once can surly be melted down again... the substacne would change you might have to cook it for longer but from where I'm standing that's logic.KSarty said:
Fun trivia: George Lucas actually refered to them as "laser swords" in early development of the first movies. I think that pretty much nails it that they hadn't even begun to think of any "plasma contained in an energy field" shenanigans as their original idea.Geo Da Sponge said:
Thats just a super powerful laser pointer. My dad actually tried buying one and it pretty much turned out to be a scam (according to him). Took his money, never answered e-mails or phone calls, and no uber pointer.Kungfu_Teddybear said:
That happened to Wolverine?nomad240 said:
If that's the case, one could wonder if that included the adamantium skeleton as well. I mean the adamantium coating of his bones and the blades and all that aren't a natural part of his biological body after all, but something that got implanted.
A drop of blood doesn't contain any bones, so it shouldn't be able to regenerate an unnatural metal skeleton. But then again, if we're talking Marvel comics, then we're talking Marvel comics...
Yeah, but wasn't there a scene from Star Wars: The phantom menace. Where Obi Wan's Jedi Master (I think his name was Quigon Jin, I could be mistaken) was trying to cut through massive steel doors that some Aliens had put up to protect themselves, and if memory serves me correctly he couldn't slice through it like butter, it actually took time. So according to that movie, some physical substances could hold off a light saber for a certain amount of time.Blights said:
You don't say? I would never have guessed that that's what he was originally thinking. But you're resolutely missing my point so that you can be all grumpy and bitter over it. What George Lucas was originally thinking is irrelevant because it wasn't important at the time. That's because the films were still good and there was no demand for detailed technical speculation. But since then the level of continuity has overflowed and most of the big things that came out of the franchise have gone to shit. So over analysed canon is all we have left, and I'm trying to make the most of it.Housebroken Lunatic said:
