Hmm, this is actually a difficult one for me.
I find I'm generally easy to please, so when someone says a film/book/game had no depth or was uninteresting or whatever I tend to say something like "I didn't see anything wrong with it". Which of course doesn't mean I love everything, it just means that there seem to be very few things I actively dislike.
It makes me wonder why I bother to get other people's opinion on things, especially things I like. Sometimes I even start to wonder if I remember things correctly.
As to something that people rave about and I don't like, the only thing that springs immediately to mind (after a quick sweep of my games collection) is Resistance: Fall of Man. I got it very cheap second hand so it's no big loss, but I found it painful to play. No wonder the PS3 bombed at first if this was the best they could offer. Maybe it's becuase it felt so different to games like COD but I just couldn't enjoy it.
In response to everyone saying Bioshock, I'll say that at first, I didn't get the fuss either. It felt like a pretty average FPS with clunky controls and a "scary" setting. I recently replayed it on Survivor mode (I'm a trophy whore okay), and my opinion totally changed. I just felt so sucked into the whole experience it was amazing. (Insert standard gushing review here) I will admit that since my previous playthrough I had upgraded to an HDTV, so that helped a bit I'm sure.
Danzaivar said:
Arkham Asylum. I swear I must be playing a different game to everyone else...
Usually I would not pick up on it when someone says they don't like something (to each his own etc), but to me AA just felt so right. It wasn't without flaw, but most of the individual elements worked great and it was tied together so well by the fact that it was, in my mind, the best possible experience of actually being Batman I could imagine.
I guess you are somewhat a fan of Batman, and so I assume you just didn't get the same feeling I did of being right in Batman's shoes (boots?).
I'm not trying to discount your opinion, but as you may have gathered by my first few paragraphs I'm usually quite an apathetic person, but Batman actually made me feel excited to play it so I thought I'd share
