DC Rebirth Closes New 52, Brings back pre-Flashpoint.
- Thread starter circularlogic88
- Start date
Recommended Videos
I'm glad I don't have to deal with this for awhile. I got into comics not that long ago and am just focusing on some of Batman's classics right now. I'm knee deep in Morrison's run and am gonna hit Battle for the Cowl before moving on with Dick and Damian. After that probably Knightfall and No Man's Land. It's just easier to read the old trades than try to follow what's going on now.
Other books I've read...
-Year One
-DKR
-Killing Joke
-Hush
-New 52 up until Zero Year
-Morrison up to Death of Bruce Wayne
-Final Crisis + RIP missing chapters
Other books I've read...
-Year One
-DKR
-Killing Joke
-Hush
-New 52 up until Zero Year
-Morrison up to Death of Bruce Wayne
-Final Crisis + RIP missing chapters
This is bad.
For one, Watchmen does not mesh well with a traditional comics universe.
For two, the insinuations being made and the blame cast at Watchmen seem to miss the point of Watchmen as well as avoiding the fact that the people casting the blame at Watchmen for the direction of DC comics (like Didio and Johns) are the people who are actually responsible for that direction - not a 30 year old comic.
For three, the people responsible for this new shake-up and direction are the same people responsible for the last several shake-ups and new directions. I don't really have much faith that this is the time they'll get it right. It's like sticking in an abusive relationship because this time they've changed.
It's not some random flash in the pan event like most but can be considered something that has been built up to for 100 or so issues of Fantastic Four, FF, Avengers and New Avenger all done by Hickman, one of the best comic writers around today. Even the tie-ins are great.
Also it didn't really adjust continuity at all apart from bringing a few ultimate universe characters over as that line was ending. It was more like an Age of Apocalypse deal where it shows a dystopian alternate reality and then the end of the event reverts everything back.
However they'd already introduced pre-new 52 Superman a year ago so while the New 52 Superman who died may stay dead, it's going to turn out he was never the main Superman anyway.
For one, Watchmen does not mesh well with a traditional comics universe.
For two, the insinuations being made and the blame cast at Watchmen seem to miss the point of Watchmen as well as avoiding the fact that the people casting the blame at Watchmen for the direction of DC comics (like Didio and Johns) are the people who are actually responsible for that direction - not a 30 year old comic.
For three, the people responsible for this new shake-up and direction are the same people responsible for the last several shake-ups and new directions. I don't really have much faith that this is the time they'll get it right. It's like sticking in an abusive relationship because this time they've changed.
Your loss, Secret Wars is one of the best event comics that has ever been written.jademunky said:
It's not some random flash in the pan event like most but can be considered something that has been built up to for 100 or so issues of Fantastic Four, FF, Avengers and New Avenger all done by Hickman, one of the best comic writers around today. Even the tie-ins are great.
Also it didn't really adjust continuity at all apart from bringing a few ultimate universe characters over as that line was ending. It was more like an Age of Apocalypse deal where it shows a dystopian alternate reality and then the end of the event reverts everything back.
He died yesterday.jademunky said:
However they'd already introduced pre-new 52 Superman a year ago so while the New 52 Superman who died may stay dead, it's going to turn out he was never the main Superman anyway.
Honestly...This seems pretty par for the course for me at least compared with most of the other big crossover events I've read from DC.
A big emphasis on alternate timelines or realities? Check.
Multiple versions of the same character? Check.
Appearances by obscure characters or those previously disconnected from the mainstream DC universe.
Also I feel I should offer my support for the New 52 as an alternate view to all the hate its getting here. There were a lot of very good stories there.
Finally I think we're forgetting the most important thing here that if the Watchmen characters do actually appear in person in this comic will they be presented accurately? Specifically whether Dr Manhattan will be letting it all hang out...
A big emphasis on alternate timelines or realities? Check.
Multiple versions of the same character? Check.
Appearances by obscure characters or those previously disconnected from the mainstream DC universe.
Also I feel I should offer my support for the New 52 as an alternate view to all the hate its getting here. There were a lot of very good stories there.
Finally I think we're forgetting the most important thing here that if the Watchmen characters do actually appear in person in this comic will they be presented accurately? Specifically whether Dr Manhattan will be letting it all hang out...
Oh I did read Secret Wars, I just never read anything else after it. The story itself was.....ok. Certainly fun although I was probably not supposed to be rooting for Dr. Doom (Seriously, he saved reality!). Mostly I just resent the crossover for interrupting the story I was invested in, specifically Spider-man (Whom, I might add, was barely in the main secret wars story at all).Overhead said:
There's a few small things it also did. Matt Murdock's identity became hidden again (it's not clear whether that was secret war or something else) and Old Man Logan is floating around as well.Captain Marvelous said:
Edit: But yeah it's not really any huge changes.
jademunky said:
Wait, they did secret wars again and Doom came out on top again? What was the fatal flaw of his plan that was his undoing?
Essentially, the prelude involves the beyonders causing the destruction of the multiverse with all the world's heroes and governments being powerless to stop it. Doom, Dr. Strange and molecule man make one last ditch effort to stop the multiversepocalypse and are partially successful. They are able to steal the power of the beyonders and make a patch work world with Doom as it's God-Emperor (and this is just the setup for the actual story).minkus_draconus said:
And yes, he is basically undone due to his own ego and insecurity.
