Earth is invaded, then we win.

[Kriptonite]

The more practical side of me wants to say execute them. Can even kind of justify it since they were apparently fine with coming over there to take our world and enslave us. They're all scum anyway.

I'd say imprison them though. Don't feel comfortable with the idea of sentencing people to death if we can just imprison them.

You'd rather rot in a prison being questioned for the rest of your life? Well, people have different opinions and preferences but that doesn't make one right or wrong. Personally though, I'd much rather die that live in a prison for the remainder of my time. Unless I have a chance of escape!

 

[spectrenihlus]

Wipe them out...

All of them.

 

[Chevalier noir]

So hey wait, if they have mastered interstellar travel they will most certainly win in round 2.

I for one embrace our alien overlords. You say they enslaved us right? Like manual labor or sex slaves? How hot are these aliens?

 

[Atmos Duality]

My personal philosophy of "valuable life" (summarized):
1) Sapience (rational intelligence) is valued, no matter what species possesses it.

2) The assumption of sapience assumes that the species must make some intention of using it, and is capable of reason. (This assumption would hold true for any space-faring species, at least at some point of their development. It's impossible for them to have achieved space travel without some form of cooperation, simply due to the scale of the sciences involved, and cooperation is a social function for intelligent beings, ergo, reason must exist.)

3) Following 1 and 2, if communications or appeal to reason break down entirely, that's when I resort to more difficult methods: Is it more cruel to imprison indefinitely, to execute, or to study the species.

Depending on how the situation unfolds, a more pragmatic response might be necessary.

Keeping in mind, that under these values, individuals and organizations who are capable of reason are held to their actions regardless of species or race. Any sentient being who makes choices must deal with the consequences.

EDIT: Changed wording for accuracy.

 

[Yeager942]

If alerting the motherworld is a problem, wouldn't the radio silence that occurs after the human victory alert them that we won? It all seems kind of moot seeing as we'd just be reconquered.

 

[Redlin5_v1legacy]

Underground bunkers. Kept alive and well but to be used as hostages should they return to invade again. If negotiations are possible they could be a useful bargaining chip seeing as we cannot stand up to them militarily when they are in full force.

Rebuild, try to improve our defences, hope for the best. If they do blow us up to kingdom come we'll take the colonists with us.

 

[greatcheezer2021]

if we've come so far to push interstellar beings off of our planet back to where ever the hell they came from kinda like a half-life: episode 2 (3?) situation, we'll most likely turn them into a food source and turn their shit against them.

i dont know. if earth was invaded, i doubt we'd survive fairly long. we'd probably be all shipped off to camps where they'd eat US. and we'd be the equivalent of alien bacon.

 

[Atmos Duality]

sentience doesn't mean what I think you think it does... you should be saying sapient or sophont... sentience refers to the capacity to feel sensations, such as pain; thus, most animals are sentient.

Thanks for the correction.
I occasionally fuck my definitions up.

 

[Lunar Templar]

i shall reply with a quote, not sure who exactly said it first though

"suffer not the alien to live" - 40K

since -.- the setup seem pretty biased against the surviving aliens anyway ...

 

[Jedamethis]

I'm sure most of them would be killed no matter what the people in power decide. Accidents happen...

 

[Frostbyte]

When I saw this, I thought: Episode 3 plot! And actually, this would make a pretty good Ep3.
OT: Imprison all the military people, except for the leaders, and negotiate with them. If that fails, then to hell with them. They can die.

 

[Clebold]

Are you aware of the story of Hernan Cortez and the Aztecs? No? WELL THATS WHATS GONNA HAPPEN!

 

[Do4600]

Study the colonists, find out their weaknesses and technology, use the remaining colonists as bulk slave labor and establish a quick and dirty military oligarchy.

"They learned the hard way that the reason humanity had decided to study war no more was that humans were so very, very good at it."

 

[Do4600]

Treat them as POW's. Its the only reasonable thing to do. If we condemn them as monsters for their militaries actions and kill them, we become no better than those we condemn.

This isn't about who is better, you can't be a better person than something that isn't human. Just like you can't be a better person than ebola.

 

[senordesol]

Treat them as POW's. Its the only reasonable thing to do. If we condemn them as monsters for their militaries actions and kill them, we become no better than those we condemn.

This isn't about who is better, you can't be a better person than something that isn't human. Just like you can't be a better person than ebola.

Sentience counts for nothing, eh?

 

[Do4600]

Treat them as POW's. Its the only reasonable thing to do. If we condemn them as monsters for their militaries actions and kill them, we become no better than those we condemn.

This isn't about who is better, you can't be a better person than something that isn't human. Just like you can't be a better person than ebola.

Sentience counts for nothing, eh?

Not if the first thing they did when they came into town is killed a couple billion people and enslaved the planet.

Any sapient life form that does that to a different sapient life form should not be treated as sapient, they should be treated as a more clever disease, only something that can be eradicated to the betterment of mankind. At the very least until they recognize and respect us enough to feel the need for diplomacy, because at that point we'll know they see us as equals.