Why would Movie Bob attack a movie for having an iffy, silly plot (Eli, Jennifer's Body)? Is this not what the Game Overthinker craves in contemporary gaming ("Why not a monkey?")?
I am not saying the above movies are good, but they can be attacked on something other than their premise. In fact, I really think a movies premise being silly, surreal, or not entirely possible should be a good thing. In the end, however, the premise is small potatoes and nil when compared to acting, directing, storytelling, foleying, gaffering, and running craft services. A good movie can be made from any premise.
As to the character of God ruining a store: Akallabeth (fall of Numenor). Yeah, you know Numenor has gone too far and that the Vala will likely win, but Iluvatar himself coming to make it a certainty was still awesome. The Akallabeth would not have been as good if Numenor did not even prompt outrage and reaction from the Almighty.
