SpiderJerusalem said:
Daria.Morgendorffer said:
No, I'm perfectly reasonable and lucid in, and entitled to, my opinion. And frankly, I find the ad hominem here entirely unnecessary
Yes, yes you are. I was just pointing out that while all kinds of opinions can be acknowledged, you must realize the slight discrepancy in assuming that only certain "enlightened" people can realize the hackiness of a multi award winning, celebrated and generally well loved writer and director?
Might I remind you that Stephany Meyer was also a celebrated and well-loved writer in her sphere as well? Popularity is nothing more than an accident of circumstance.
And Joss Whedon is a shit writer. He has no sense of characterization. He only knows how to write two types of characters - smug, sarcastic bad-asses and bimbos - and his "wit" is nothing more than pandering to nerds who used to use sarcastic quips to feel superior to bullies. In the end, his characters all sounds the same because they all make the same kinds of statements; there's not a single line one of them might say that you can't imagine them all saying, because they're all sarcastic, smug dipshits who can't resist making a "clever" remark when there's an opportunity.
Think about how Captain America was portrayed in his first movie. He was a polite, friendly, sometimes awkward, but an extremely motivated young man who got lucky and happened to be picked for the super-soldier project because he had the right personality that the doctor was looking for.
Now tell me, what about that kind of character strikes you as responding to Tony Stark saying "Oh, somebody here speaks English" with "Oh, so that's what that was," in a smug voice, because hurr hurr, he are so clevurr! Or cock-fighting with another character with lines like "Big man in a suit! Take that away and what are you?" as if he were a high school bully trying to talk down the smart kid in class?
When it comes to character writing, Joss Whedon has no talent.
Edit: My apologies to Lieju. I accidentally clicked the quote button to the wrong person's post and then didn't realize it was still there when I posted.