Everyone does.
Especially if you've gamed for over 20 years.
I always manage to keep, and know exactly where my shittiest games of all time are. Even in obscure places, in the attic for instance. Like "Monster Truck Madness" for PC, or "Deadly Towers" for NES. I will always know where they are; "At the end of the pile about 3 inches from the bottom in that box stored in the corner with 7 other boxes piled perpendicular and on top of it. The box has a torn flap, and the flaps are not tucked into each other, but the flaps of the box on top of it are. The box also smells like a sock, and I last saw the game 7 years ago. I think the game has a torn label as well." Yup, that's where it is, and it's torn across the title.
But when I need to find the disc for Company of Heroes or something interesting like that.. well, sometimes it's an ordeal.