Fallout 1&2 - These games were the bomb, they had the perfect atmosphere and gameplay for an RPG.
Morrowind - Yes, despite my now rampant hate of Bethesda, Morrowind (Or "Oblivion without the dumbing down" has got to be one of my favourite games which feature elves. In fact, it's my only favourite game that features elves.
Overlord - I lied, this also features elves. First of all, it's written by the daughter of Sir Terry Fucking Pratchett, second of all, the old minion horde gameplay isn't seen enough in games today, and thirdly, fuck was it fun to send the minions into a house and then watch the smoke come from the doorway as they destroyed the place.
Saint's Row 2 - The last word in random, pointless, wacky fun, the customisability is to die for, but the only problem is the personality of the guy. Namely, he's a moron.
Evil Genius - EVERY one of us has read at least one of those "How to bea good Evil Genius" sheets which make fun of the cliches of Bond and stuff, well prepare for a flip in the pseudo-opposite direction. This game makes fun of the cliches, but by including EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM. From the big bosomed female agent who's special attacks are as feminine as an army of Martha Stewarts, to the powerful personal henchmen, this game has. It. All.