Mass Effect! Sure the graphics were great, if you sat around and waited for them to load, but after that, all the planets and stations were exact copies of one another, the inventory handling was terrible and only 3 missions into the game, I've already lost a third of my "playable" characters! WTF? I never even got a chance to actually have them in the party before they started dying! All that hype for a 6 - 7 hour game... Halo ODST actually lasted longer... perhaps due to multiplayer, but still!