Another vote for stealth, in all its varieties. Dishonored and Deus Ex give me ghosting: come in, do what you need to do, and leave with none the wiser. The Arkham games give me predator: the bad guys KNOW you're there, they just can't stop you, or even find you, until the last gibbering fool is cowering in the corner. Skyrim let me kill a dungeon of bandits without them knowing I was hunting them.
Anything that gives me superhuman agility and dexterity: Witcher 3, Geralt can flick an arrow right back at an attacker and kill them with it. In Dragon's Dogma, my Strider killed a giant Cyclops, backflipped off it onto the back of a second Cyclops to continue the fight, without ever touching the ground. Glorious!
Anything that lets me turn enemies against each other. I guess it's not a Jedi Mind Trick, it's more like something a Sith Lord would do.