Jandau said:
This thread shows that a lot of people don't know the difference between a "ripoff" and a "homage" or a "reference"...
Stop that right now! Common sense has no place in these fair forums! Away with thee!
Achem...I agree, however. None of the examples presented so far pass muster unless one is willing to use extremely loose definitions of what a 'rip-off' constitutes, as, every example has either had wholly it's own story/plot and unique variation of theme/setting/characters, or has been an official derivative of another work, i.e. Lord of the Rings.
Taking a single element, like Space Marines, or Zombies, or a setting and holding that up as proof of a rip-off is just silly, as it ignores every single other factor that distinguishes the game from the book, or movie that it bears similarity to.