It's only controversial to a minority of people.Zayren said:I've got a feeling Dead Island will be bad. Making something controversial to get people to buy it seems cheap.
My real concern is that they pull a Halo, and make the trailers all weepy, and when you get to the actual game you're confronted by John the Spartan and Sgt Johnson (I still can't get over that) the angry black soldier man.
Other than a very old, very short tech demo though, I've not seen anything of the game, so I won't comment.
I don't think any of the major titles will be bad, TOR and Human Revolution have both had excellent previews, Dragon Age 2 has had a fantastic review from PCG, Mass Effect 3 is... Well, fucking Mass Effect(!), and Skyrim is Oblivion but better (I loved Oblivion, forgive me Morrowinders).
Then there's LA Noire, Crysis 2, Uncharted 3 and inFamous 2. I really cannot see any of the top tier stuff approaching anything like average, let alone bad, unless something goes really wrong.