LordCuthberton said:
I disagree. It is a subjective topic though.
Personally, I thought that it was a good ending, you are mirroring the heroic actions that your own father performed. You enter the deadly chamber, but you need a code!
What's that code?
The bible reference. The arc words that your parents reminded you of throughout your life, as it comes full circle and you input the bible number.
It's epic. It's a ending! And it works so very well with the prevelant dramatic imagery.
Hence why I thought it was a good ending.
Okay, I'll buy that as a reasonable response to like it, but having Fawkes standing right next to you ruins it completely. None of the above is necessary if Fawkes is just there, rad resistant and everything.
The whole 'full circle' thing is a good way to end a game, but it should be the player's decision (and i don't count needlessly sending another person to die as a viable alternative).
Thankfully, I think this is absolved with the latest DLC, but it seems like a sham to force DLC on the player, just to get a satisfactory ending, where you can sensibly react to the situation.