3 big ones for me.
Alice: Madness Returns. The first game was an epic balance between thriller and twisted childs story, in this game its too colourful, too pretty, there arent enough disturbing moments in it to excite the very dead inner child of mine.
Torchlight: Diehard diablo fan hates a diablo clone? Why? Its too easy, too colourful, lacks any depth, i mean you just keep going straight down without even really knowing why? and the skills are overkill... The alchemists kamehameha technique can wipe out a room in a few seconds...
Saints row the Third: Saints row 2 perfect game, you even keep playing it once you finish it cos ya know, youve earned the city, now after being the biggest badass you get transported (for some reason) to a new place and have to start all over again with a char whos still full of himself as if he still owns the place...