Settlers 7:
Many new ideas, but they just don't work well, I liked Settlers 6 though.
You get only a handful of maps ? forgot how many but less than 10, that is just too little for that price.
And you have to register with EA? and can only play the game when beeing online with them.
Aion (original with no expansion):
Forced pvp and poor attempt at westernizing it. Oh and the 10 hour login waits.
Civilization 5:
A more boring and slow version of all the previous civs, now in hexa dimension grid.
Everything is the same, just with a bit more detail and rounds that take so long you forget what your plans were.
Have to register civ 5 with Steam is the only way to be allowed to play it .. it is now bound to your Steam account and can never be unbound (official reply).
Oblivion:
Might be stepping on some toes, but having played mmorpgs for a decade, Oblivion was just BLEH. Graphics were ok but only as good as the best mmorpgs, handling was awful with the stupid 1st person view that works so poorly in Oblivion. For a mmorpg gamer Oblivion will feel rather simple.
Sid Meyers Railroads:
The "newest" version of railroad tycoon. If the game actually worked, it would not be so bad but the railroad line laying can't be done so your trains do what is expected (dont take my word for it, it is common knowledge on forums). So I opened my old drawer and found Railroad Tycoon 2 Gold, which .. yes you guessed it is not made by firafax/sid meyer.
Dragon Age origins:
A step downwards from the great bioware tradition of Baldurs gate and NeverWinterNights series. Poor combat handling, your characters always does silly things even after all AI is turned off. Extremely linear console like gameplay, and the story line is not quite up to standard with older games from Bioware. And then the reminder to buy extra content in thegame .. urrgh that is a turnoff. Looking at videos and reviews from DA2 really made me doubt Bioware as the quality game maker they have always been.