Getting raped is like getting a flat tire. Also, it's God's will. Fancy that.

Recommended Videos

Astoria

New member
Oct 25, 2010
1,887
0
0
In every stupid argument like this it is always brought up that it is 'God's will'. You can tell no one in their family has been raped. How do people like this get in charge?
 

Kopikatsu

New member
May 27, 2010
4,924
0
0
Astoria said:
How do people like this get in charge?
Er...people vote them into office. Then when they come up for re-election, they vote them back into office. I highly doubt that both of these men won't be re-elected. That's just how the government (and voters!) work. At least, that's how it works in 'merica.
 

Meggiepants

Not a pigeon roost
Jan 19, 2010
2,536
0
0
Souplex said:
meganmeave said:
Souplex said:
meganmeave said:
Yeah, I heard about this shit. I'm going to say it first. This is what happens when the majority of lawmakers are men. Yeah, I know, that's simplistic. But I still think it's true. Very few men have ever felt the fear of being raped. I can't think of a single woman over 30 who hasn't at some point been terribly afraid of just this thing.
It has less to do with being a man and more to do with being an idiot in this case.
Not all men are idiots.
A higher number than I find acceptable are, but I'm working on that.
Educate dem men!

While I agree in part with this, I personally have found the people with the most cavalier attitude about rape do tend to be old men. And unfortunately, Congress is overstuffed with old men.
Well why do you look towards the men half and ignore the old half?
Many politicos are too old to be in touch with America.
Well, mostly because more than 90% of politicos, old or otherwise, are men. Let's just say it doesn't help.
 

maturin

New member
Jul 20, 2010
702
0
0
Grospoliner said:
I'm sorry. But to say that the man's statements are trivializing it is a longshot.

The man says "We should plan ahead for circumstances which might be out of our control" and then goes on to say. "I have a tire in my car and insurance". Because you don't get in a car and drive any sort of distance without being prepared for a blow out, and you don't go through life without having the capacity to get back on your feet after a horrible accident.

So the idea that he's trivializing it, is simply stupid.

Now what is a problem is him saying that preparedness is important while gutting insurance mandates that permit women to have abortions and instead requiring them to purchase additional coverage for it. That IS deplorable and he should be called out on that rather than some imaginary claim that he's trivializing rape in the name of God or some such nonsense.
Ding, ding.

I was expecting to see this article on Huffington Post. Their reaction to reactionaries usually involves a heavy dose of interpretation in order to come up with a sensational headline. And they're usually the ones complaining about the inflammatory rhetoric and irrational hyberbole of Republicans or (ironically) the blatant bias of Fox News. Cool your jets, my fellow left-wingers. The chauvinism and class warfare coming out of this rash of new GOP politicians is triggering plenty of productive backlash without you having to look silly getting the word out.
 

pokepuke

New member
Dec 28, 2010
139
0
0
Raskolnikov34 said:
This ignores the Doctrine of Free Will though. God has given Man the power to choose to the good or the evil; ie: he didn't create robots to blindly follow him because that would have defeated the purpose of creating them in the first place. It also ignores the fallen nature of Man, which would explain where evil comes from.

I don't want to start a religious war over this though (I'm a Roman Catholic btw).
Yep, just forget about the part where God is said to have created man, thus creating the entire timeline of events that will happen to him. Other than that.... free will!
 

Raskolnikov34

New member
Jun 10, 2011
105
0
0
pokepuke said:
Raskolnikov34 said:
This ignores the Doctrine of Free Will though. God has given Man the power to choose to the good or the evil; ie: he didn't create robots to blindly follow him because that would have defeated the purpose of creating them in the first place. It also ignores the fallen nature of Man, which would explain where evil comes from.

I don't want to start a religious war over this though (I'm a Roman Catholic btw).
Yep, just forget about the part where God is said to have created man, thus creating the entire timeline of events that will happen to him. Other than that.... free will!
And how does God creating Man, setting into motion all the future chain of events, rob him of his free will? I don't really follow that...
 

Astoria

New member
Oct 25, 2010
1,887
0
0
Kopikatsu said:
Astoria said:
How do people like this get in charge?
Er...people vote them into office. Then when they come up for re-election, they vote them back into office. I highly doubt that both of these men won't be re-elected. That's just how the government (and voters!) work. At least, that's how it works in 'merica.
It wasn't a proper question I know how it works. I was just pointing out that its unbelieveable that people actually elect and re elect these people.
 

SteewpidZombie

New member
Dec 31, 2010
545
0
0
Well then...I guess if the world is to end in 2012, the first sign will be that Kansas and Idaho get wiped off the earth in a hail of fire...kinda like Sodom and Gomorrah. (Just kidding...COME AT ME BRO!)

Though as soon as that happens, I'll be working on my giant wooden (surprisingly able to float) ship that shalt have 2 of every creature upon it. There shall be 2 of every species: 2 of every dog, 2 of every Tom Cruise and Charlie Sheen (SSSSSHUUUUSH! Don't Tell Nobody About The Clones), 2 of every Nyancat, and 2 of every Furry...UPON WENCE! WE SHALT REBUILD THE EARTH UPON THE FOUNDATION OF INTERNET MEMES!

(Hey don't be getting mad at me, it was that one official that said that Rape was a good thing and God willed it to happen, thus you must already know that up is down and black is white. Heck I'll even bet that rocks can talk and that the end of the world just got postponed this year).

(Note: Yes my sarcasm is vast...but can ya honestly blame me?)
 

DracoSuave

New member
Jan 26, 2009
1,685
0
0
Damura said:
According to the article these answers were in response to incest-rape as well. Forget adults. How the fuck is an underage girl supposed to anticipate that her brother or father or uncle is going to rape her?
Or abortion insurance given that children can't afford basic medical....

So, in Kansas, get your young daughter... abortion insurance.

Morality issues aside, abortion is a legal service in the state of Kansas, and the medical institutions have a means to pay for such already included in the system. The government does not have the right to interfere with this process simply because it does not like the legality of it.

If you don't like it, pass a law, make it illegal, and hope it stands up in the supreme court. Do not make it harder to attain for those who do not share the same religious beliefs as you. This is why I believe strongly in the separation of the church and the state; when the state passes laws based on religious tenets, it always acts as a means to suppress those who do not heed those tenets.

The only countries that have freedom of religion are those with freedom from religion.
 

Rule Britannia

New member
Apr 20, 2011
883
0
0
This is why I make fun of America being sterotypically dumb....I am British stereotypically I drink tea 24/7 have the worst teeth on the planet and lots of other things I'm sure...

This whole article just shows dumbness... wear 7,000 layers of bubblewrap...You need to be prepared to get hit by a train or a car or even a pack of bulls....

Being raped is entirely circumstantial...If the female chooses to wear certain clothes, if they choose to go to different parts of town or whatever... I heard a dumb statistic that "4 in 10 women have been raped"....I will not believe that whatsoever....I won't even believe 1 in 10....1 in 20 or 1 in 30 seems more realistic to me. I have also heard that most rape victims are in college...this seems somewhat believable...but hey, I'm not in college nor am I a girl sooooo.....
 

WorldCritic

New member
Apr 13, 2009
3,021
0
0
Well, I know I can't exactly assume all of Kansas is like that, but thanks to that guy I now have a reason to stay away.
 

Kopikatsu

New member
May 27, 2010
4,924
0
0
SteewpidZombie said:
Well then...I guess if the world is to end in 2012, the first sign will be that Kansas and Idaho get wiped off the earth in a hail of fire...kinda like Sodom and Gomorrah. (Just kidding...COME AT ME BRO!)

Though as soon as that happens, I'll be working on my giant wooden (surprisingly able to float) ship that shalt have 2 of every creature upon it. There shall be 2 of every species: 2 of every dog, 2 of every Tom Cruise and Charlie Sheen (SSSSSHUUUUSH! Don't Tell Nobody About The Clones), 2 of every Nyancat, and 2 of every Furry...UPON WENCE! WE SHALT REBUILD THE EARTH UPON THE FOUNDATION OF INTERNET MEMES!

(Hey don't be getting mad at me, it was that one official that said that Rape was a good thing and God willed it to happen, thus you must already know that up is down and black is white. Heck I'll even bet that rocks can talk and that the end of the world just got postponed this year).

(Note: Yes my sarcasm is vast...but can ya honestly blame me?)
...Wood is very buoyant and makes wonderful boats. I don't understand why you would think a wooden ship floating is surprising.
 

kasperbbs

New member
Dec 27, 2009
1,855
0
0
So he said that insurance shouldn't cover abortions for people that got pregnant by accident and not by getting raped? I'm ok with that if that's the case. People are such drama queens.
 

MasterChief892039

New member
Jun 28, 2010
631
0
0
This is the problem with having a bunch of men discussing women's issues. Considering that >10% of rape victims are male and male victims don't have to deal with pregnancy (and considering that males in general aren't conditioned to be in constant fear of being raped), men just don't have the education or personal experience to deal with this kind of subject.

And when you throw religion into the mix, it just becomes a shitshow.

Rule Britannia said:
Being raped is entirely circumstantial...If the female chooses to wear certain clothes, if they choose to go to different parts of town or whatever... I heard a dumb statistic that "4 in 10 women have been raped"....I will not believe that whatsoever....I won't even believe 1 in 10....1 in 20 or 1 in 30 seems more realistic to me. I have also heard that most rape victims are in college...this seems somewhat believable...but hey, I'm not in college nor am I a girl sooooo.....
The statistic is that 4 in 10 women will be sexually assaulted in their lifetimes, not raped. The statistic includes things like gropings but it's certainly not a made-up number. It's also a fallacy that women are more likely to be raped in certain kinds of clothing, though you're right that they're more likely to be assaulted while attending college/university. However that would mean with shouldn't attend post-secondary education by your logic, as we'd be bringing it upon ourselves by "choosing to go to that part of town"... which is absurd.
 

SteewpidZombie

New member
Dec 31, 2010
545
0
0
Kopikatsu said:
SteewpidZombie said:
Well then...I guess if the world is to end in 2012, the first sign will be that Kansas and Idaho get wiped off the earth in a hail of fire...kinda like Sodom and Gomorrah. (Just kidding...COME AT ME BRO!)

Though as soon as that happens, I'll be working on my giant wooden (surprisingly able to float) ship that shalt have 2 of every creature upon it. There shall be 2 of every species: 2 of every dog, 2 of every Tom Cruise and Charlie Sheen (SSSSSHUUUUSH! Don't Tell Nobody About The Clones), 2 of every Nyancat, and 2 of every Furry...UPON WENCE! WE SHALT REBUILD THE EARTH UPON THE FOUNDATION OF INTERNET MEMES!

(Hey don't be getting mad at me, it was that one official that said that Rape was a good thing and God willed it to happen, thus you must already know that up is down and black is white. Heck I'll even bet that rocks can talk and that the end of the world just got postponed this year).

(Note: Yes my sarcasm is vast...but can ya honestly blame me?)
...Wood is very buoyant and makes wonderful boats. I don't understand why you would think a wooden ship floating is surprising.
It's not that it's wood, it's rather that I can barely operate basic power tools without damaging something. Plus I'm pretty sure that building a massive ship that can hold 2 of EVERYTHING would be kinda massive and heavy...and full of holes...I'll need to get Home Depot to help build this thing...
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
Kopikatsu said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
Zaik said:
Overdramatized.

This thread, that article, and rape in general. It's all over dramatized.

I wouldn't equate it with a spare tire, but I wouldn't equate it with a mind shattering life altering experience either.

Also the whole making abortions legally implausible(the actual issue of the article, not the shock jock attention grabber) is just going to end up with a lot of self abortions again, I can't wait for the backfire. I want to never understand the train of thought that these guys follow, but unfortunately I do understand it.
I agree with this poster fully.

Also is homeboy not right? Are you not suppose to buy health insurance? Car insurance? Shit happens in this world people. You might get mugged. You might get raped. Your house may catch on fire. You could get in an autoaccident with a drunk driver and be paralyzed.
Vault101 said:
Zaik said:
Overdramatized.

This thread, that article, and rape in general. It's all over dramatized.

I wouldn't equate it with a spare tire, but I wouldn't equate it with a mind shattering life altering experience either.

Also the whole making abortions legally implausible(the actual issue of the article, not the shock jock attention grabber) is just going to end up with a lot of self abortions again, I can't wait for the backfire. I want to never understand the train of thought that these guys follow, but unfortunately I do understand it.
*coughtrollcough*
Gaiz, he can't both have a valid point AND be a troll. So, which is it? (Mostly directed at Vault101). Feel like supporting that 'troll' point? :x
I was about to feed him and then I remembered he's a troll (of the women hating variety)

anyway my point was going to be "ever been raped?" because I think if you havnt been raped you have no right to besically say "oh cmon..it couldnt have been THAT bad" sure its worse for some than others..and people probably deal with it in different ways
 

BabyRaptor

New member
Dec 17, 2010
1,505
0
0
icame said:
So... can we get these obvious retards thrown out of office? There really needs to be a way to do that if enough people are against them.
Well, look at Wisconsin. The people got riled up enough to put together recalls, so what do the Republicans do? Start openly bragging about running fake candidates in said recalls to try and Fuck them up. There's no winning with people who believe that only they should be in charge.

On topic, that is just sickening. It's as bad as Sharon Angle saying that women who are raped should just make lemonade. Or Sarah PayMe making rape victims pay for their own rape kits.

Then again, when you hold the view that women are property, anything goes I guess.
 

Terminal Blue

Elite Member
Legacy
Feb 18, 2010
3,933
1,804
118
Country
United Kingdom
FarleShadow said:
Essentially, De Graaf suggests that insurance for events you cannot predict is a good idea, he makes the mistake of suggesting that, like a flat tire, rape is a random event, then some assholes decide that he's the next hitler and try to lynch him.
You've rather missed the point.

It's not so much that he's suggesting rape is a random event, but that a large proportion of the population should actively spend time planning for the eventuality. It is also the context in which he's saying it, it pretty much comes down to 'expect to be raped, and then expect not to be able to do anything about it after the fact'.

The issue is not that he equates rape with a random event, but that his suggestion is that people should be prepared for it. I.e. that women should invest time into thinking about the

FarleShadow said:
Sorry kids, I don't buy the 'but he's a man' excuse, women and men both have holes and they're all equally 'open' to being raped.
Which would be a very welcome fact if any demonstrable statistical or experiential equivallence held it up, but it doesn't. Rape is by definition not a gender neutral crime, it is fundamentally linked to the implicit power dynamics of male-female intercourse.

Having a penis put in you is consistently understood as a 'feminine' position, this applies whether the victim is male or female. Rape only works as a definition because it references the female body and its physical position within heterosexual intercourse, without the existence of that body male rape would be indistinct from any other painful assault. While this might be seen as an argument for the definition not to exist, there is an experiential lack of equivalence. Male rape is horrible, noone would deny it, it's not necessarily easier for the victim to process or deal with, but it's not the same thing and the way it is likely to be socially interpreted and experienced is very different.

Even if equivalence existed, neither the representative in question or the article are talking about male rape. They're talking about rape pregnancy, which male-bodied men don't generally have to worry about.