I like realistic more, while I like stylized games for longer.
A good example is that I'm in love with the F.E.A.R. series which not the best graphics, they still went for realism. I can't stand playing F.E.A.R. one because even if the gameplay is much better, the graphics make me puke.
While on the stylized side, JSRF has been a favorite of mine and I would sell up any game from today's standards to play it.