OhJohnNo said:
But what gets me about And Justice For All is just how blandit all is. The lead singer's voice, for example - it's not quite growling, but also not quite singing. Is it supposed to convey rage? It doesn't. Same goes for the riffs. Mind you, "One" is definitely good, so if the other albums have more songs like that...
Vocals were never Metallicas strong point.
What you have to remember is that Metallica aren't famous for being the best thrash metal band, they're famous for being the FIRST thrash metal band anyone noticed. I could list a dozen bands that are in the same genre and do it better than Metallica, but I'll just say that only "Kill em all" and "Master of Puppets" are must-listen-too's while it's not a sin to ignore the rest.