Has anyone reviewed Innocence of Muslims yet? No? Well I'm gonna.

Recommended Videos

Bara_no_Hime

New member
Sep 15, 2010
3,646
0
0
Irridium said:
Meanwhile meanwhile...



http://www.theatlanticwire.com/politics/2012/09/does-not-represent-us-moving-photos-pro-american-rallies-libya/56803/
Awesome! You go kid!

And thank you, Irridium, for making my day slightly brighter with that image. I've had a number of Islamic students, and I've liked all of them. It's always nice to get a reminder that Extremists are just that - Extreme. Not the norm.
 

Berithil

Maintenence Man of the Universe
Mar 19, 2009
1,600
0
0
My curiosity got the better of me and I just watched it....



Seriously, the only people who should be offended by this are filmmakers. If this was a film about Christians, I would just laugh my head off at how bad it was. It's so stupid I would find it hard to be offended. It's like a six year old calling you a "poop face". All you can do is laugh.
 

irishmanwithagun

New member
Mar 6, 2012
50
0
0
Frostbyte666 said:
Scrumpmonkey said:
Meanwhile...


Gah I find those pictures quite sickening and is it me or do islamists always seem to go for killing when someone spouts something their religion doesn't like, granted groups like westboro aren't much better but I don't remember them actually saying things like behead and kill but more [subject] should be ashamed and god forsakes you etc etc (please correct me if I'm wrong as I am quite ignorant in this area). The 2nd picture disgusts me because its the parents putting a sign in the childs hands and I don't think the kid can read what he's holding, I wonder what would happen if the kid refused, would the parents then beat him?

OT: never heard of this film till I read this thread and it's not going to be hard to avoid it afterwards since I am prejudiced against all religions anyway, still good to have a heads up on where not to waste 15 minutes of my life.
Islam is a lot like Christianity and Judaism, only way way WAAAAAAAAY behind the historical curve. Odds are it'll eventually even out and things and all the threats of beheadings and stonings will be remembered the same way Christians remember the Crusades, the Inquisition, Witch Trials, Nazi collaberation and the Ku Klux Klan.
 

Da Orky Man

Yeah, that's me
Apr 24, 2011
2,107
0
0
000Ronald said:
Da Orky Man said:
Now, please tell me if I missed something there, but you do know that the 13 minutes is just a trailer, right? The full movie was only shown at one screening, I believe.
I don't believe that for a second, and I won't until I see this supposed film.
No need to get angry now. Check out the article below:

http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2012/09/13/innocence-muslims-producer-identity-questioned-actors-say-were-duped/#ixzz26gzOeA5V

So, apparently it was indeed shown to a 'small viewing' in Los Angeles, with a worker there confirming a film named 'The Innocence of Bin Laden' being shown.
 

000Ronald

New member
Mar 7, 2008
2,167
0
0
Chaosritter said:
000Ronald said:
You! You! I've seen you say that a couple of times here and there. And I have a response! Not a jokey, "I have to make up a word, this is so bad" response, but an actual, rational response.

My problem isn't with the factual accuracy of the film; for my money, the question of accuracy is irrelevant. Even if he did sack cities, marry children, commit genocide, torture people, sleep with married women (and maybe men)...that can't be all he did, and that's the problem.

I can accept that revered historical figures did horrible things. FDR interned millions of Japanese-Americans during WWII. Abraham Lincoln suspended Habeus Corpus. George Washington killed millions of Native Americans. The problem is those aren't the only things they did. And even when they did do those things, they did it for a reason. This movie? It portrays Muhammad as raping children and sacking cities because he's a Muslim. But he created Islam, so...all followers of Islam are violent thugs, by that logic, which is the logic they use in the film.
Oh, it does matter indeed.

This movie has already been compared to Nazi propaganda-
OK, let me cut you off right there. Other people may be comparing this to Nazi propaganda, but I'm not. I'm personally of the opinion that Nazis made much better propaganda.

, which is usually half truths mixed with lies. This flick however does show scenes from the Koran and is as accurate as the budget allows it. There's a difference between hate speech and unpleasant truths.

Also, people tend to forget about the atrocities people commited for a "good cause". Ernesto Guevara (a.k.a. Che Guevara), Lenin, Napeoleon and so on, they all have commited crimes against humanity, killed thousands of political enemies and those who were simply at the wrong place at the wrong time, yet they are considered icons anyway. It's right and important to show people the less "heroic" side of the man who founded Islam.
There's a huge difference between showing someone's less heroic side and showing someone as a human avatar of murder and rape. Which is what I said before.

Besides, what "good" has Muhammad ever done? Jesus said "love your enemy", Muhammad said "kill the men and take the women as slaves". And I mean actual good, not just deciding to spare christians and jews when they accept being second class people and pay protection money. Countries like Iran and Pakistan are led in the way Muhammad wished it, and look how they're doing.
Well, having not read the Koran, I can't speak for Muhammad. I can however, say that Muslims in general are responsible for preserving a great deal of knowledge during the middle ages, especially stuff having to do with math and philosophy. Plus, plenty of Muslims are just good people. So there's that.

By portraying the leader of a people the way they have, and preceeding it by showing his followers, thousands of years later, performing the same things, they are saying that all Muslims are violent thugs at best and avatars of murder and rape at worst. This is called dehumanization [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehumanization] and it's the something countries do prior to declaring war. You have much more reason to attack and kill someone if you believe they're going to do you harm even if you don't, y'see.

And I know I'm (mostly) repeating myself, but you didn't say anything that you hadn't already said before. So at least I'm consistent.
 

000Ronald

New member
Mar 7, 2008
2,167
0
0
Chaosritter said:
000Ronald said:
There's a huge difference between showing someone's less heroic side and showing someone as a human avatar of murder and rape. Which is what I said before.
Avatar of murder and rape, that actually describes it prety well. Read the Koran and you'll come to the same conclusion.

Muhammad preached violence and war, and that's exactly what his followers live.
000Ronald said:
Well, having not read the Koran, I can't speak for Muhammad. I can however, say that Muslims in general are responsible for preserving a great deal of knowledge during the middle ages, especially stuff having to do with math and philosophy. Plus, plenty of Muslims are just good people. So there's that.
Preserving knowledge? Maybe you should read up what happened to the great library of Alexandria after the muslims conquered the city.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria#Arabic_sources
I did read that, actually. Most of the article says Julius Caesar burned it down, on accident. The part you directed me to? Pretty much a footnote at the bottom.

000Ronald said:
By portraying the leader of a people the way they have, and preceeding it by showing his followers, thousands of years later, performing the same things, they are saying that all Muslims are violent thugs at best and avatars of murder and rape at worst. This is called dehumanization [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehumanization] and it's the something countries do prior to declaring war. You have much more reason to attack and kill someone if you believe they're going to do you harm even if you don't, y'see.
Uhm, you have seen what's going on in the middle East lately, right?

They are violent thugs, rapists and murderers, and the holy Koran is their legitimization. Don't you think there is a reason why radical fanatics, who openly promote war, genocide and islamization got the vast majority in every democratic vote in every country of the "arabic spring"?

You should really read the Koran, then you'd know that "God" wants the muslims to fare war against everyone and everything until the entire world is islamic. He wants them to hide their intentions until they grew strong enough in numbers to take over, follow the laws of those they plot against and lie and even deny their faith if it serves their purpose.

Just look what's going on in Thailand, were several cities have a muslim majority. These guys are so out of control that the government thinks about simply leaving the cities to them and allow them to introduce sharia law because everything else would end in a blood bath. Look what's going on in Sweden, Belgium and France.

I know, calling someone a bigot racist is easier than reading through this piece of shit, but the enlightenment about the "religion of peace" is worth it.
I'm aware of all that, yes.

I'm also aware of what happened in Egypt and Libya. Of the huge organized protests worldwide. I'm aware that the entire world is just starting to drag itself out of a major economic depression, and that more and more people are extremely unsatisfied with their lives. It's like a friend of mine used to say all the damn time; "I wanna do something!"

See, there's something that's been bugging me for the past...maybe six months now. I couldn't identify quite what it was, but I do now. We're smack-dab in the middle of a huge transitional period. Culture, technology, economy, government, even the enviornment; if it can change it's changing. What we're moving into, I'm not entirely certain, but the fact that at least a third of the human race has access to the entirety of all human knowledge and piss-easy communication to anyone with the same probably has something to do with it. The tide is flowing in, and carrying with it a roaring wave of change. What a rational human being would do is do as much as they can to move the tide forward in a way that will mitigate the potential damage.

But you don't see this. You see a bunch of angry Muslims, probably because you've been trained to see angry Muslims over the past ten years by the news media. You see it, and you think, "Those angry Muslims are a problem. We should do something about this." You don't see that it's part of a much, much larger trend, either because you can't or you don't want to.

I'm not saying that rioting and murdering is a good thing; far from it. What I'm saying is that the problem, although I'm hesitant to call it a problem, is much, much larger than you make it out to be.

I...that's not what I was going to say. That's not what I wanted to say. I was going to talk about how Muslims you described were the minority, and they make news. What happened? I'm sorry, I have to gather my thoughts for a moment, I'll have a more coherent response eventually.
 

Leethe1Girl

New member
Apr 30, 2012
56
0
0
I've seen a fairly comprehensive 20-min short-version of it. And it was epic.

The worst-quality piece of shit you ever did see, with acting so bad you REALLY have to question whether or not it was just intended as a comedy... which would be less funny and more tragic all things considered.

And the fact that people get offended by this to the point of murder is THE most hilarious thing that has ever happened on this damn planet. Especially when you consider all of the the right-wing morons who feel the need to be sympathetic to the hive-minded murderers.
 

000Ronald

New member
Mar 7, 2008
2,167
0
0
Chaosritter said:
000Ronald said:
I...that's not what I was going to say. That's not what I wanted to say. I was going to talk about how Muslims you described were the minority, and they make news. What happened? I'm sorry, I have to gather my thoughts for a moment, I'll have a more coherent response eventually.
I keep hearing that those "radical" muslims are the minority, yet the vast majority gave their vote to those who strive for radical islam as soon as they got the chance. So unless the votes have been manipulated big time, they seem to at least approve of it. There is no such thing as moderate Islam, history has shown that plenty of times.

The UN might have had good intentions when they supported the "rebels", but even the most enthusiastic supporters have realized that the western world opened Pandora's box by now.
Y'know what? Fuck it, I'll get down to what I was going to say in the first place. Last step.

They have every reason to hate the U.S. We bombed them back to the middle ages. We occupied their country for a decade. We killed their people by the thousands.

There's no one there left with any sort of rational thought. And it's our damn fault. That's what it comes down to. It's our responsibility, but we can't fix it, because we broke it too damn hard.

And you have been taught to see them as less than human. Because it's easier than caring about people an entire world away. People you've been fighting for ten years. If you hate them for being different than you, if you use flimsy justifications for doing harm to their people, how are you any different than them?

No, they're not justified in murdering people over a silly terrible movie. Violence has never, ever solved anything. Ever. But we weren't justified in going to fucking war against them, either.

That's it. End of conversation. I've been writing for almost six hours, and I need to go to sleep.
 

WolfThomas

Man must have a code.
Dec 21, 2007
5,292
0
0
Bara_no_Hime said:
Ahem. "Mohammed had intolerant attitudes towards women and probably smelled poorly due to the sanitary conditions of his day making daily bathing impossible."
Can't comment on the first part. But Mohammed would probably have smelled good by his times standards and probably adequate if not great by today's standard. He'd have washed each time before praying, changed clothes often and had access to scents and perfumes (which men are allowed to wear in Islam).

Compared to most people in Europe (except the Vikings) who didn't wash or change clothes as frequently.