Homosexuality in games

Recommended Videos

DI7789

New member
Aug 30, 2008
98
0
0
Nobody remembers KotOR? Juhani and the female Jedi? (And quite a few more that don't yet come to mind). Also, Fable and Sims 2 (Obviously, they've been mentioned previously but deserve to be mentioned again). I'm not 100% sure, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was a gay sex scene in The Witcher (I'm only able to play about half an hour of that game before my computer craps out). If you've ever read a fanfiction on the internet, you will find that just about every character has mysteriously turned gay. I think Tommy (A character who had a short scene with one of the main characters in which he creeps her out with a tarot card reading) from Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy was gay (I recall there were some hints at it). There are probably more that I missed
 

keptsimple

New member
Feb 26, 2009
223
0
0
apsham said:
Florian was depicted as an over the top homosexual because he had been repressed all of his life, it was pretty much hinted at throughout the entire game that he was acting like that because that's how he felt a gay person WOULD act.
I dunno. Gay Tony, the other gay character in GTA4, is also over-the-top flamboyant. I'm willing to believe that these characters are supposed to be lampooning stereotypes, but it still doesn't come off as very funny.
 

Kiutu

New member
Sep 27, 2008
1,787
0
0
They could always make a game where the hero's love interest is anothet guy, but not treat it any more or less important than if it were a female instead. Really though, until homosexuals are truly considered equals, gay characters in games will either be very stereotyped, or non-existant, but then there will also be those that come off as homosexual or something.
 

Davey Woo

New member
Jan 9, 2009
2,468
0
0
If anyone's looking for an overtly camp character, try Zhang He off of Dynasty Warriors.
Wears make-up and tight fitting clothes and never shuts up about beauty... Weird guy that one.

Just to clarify I'm not anti gay/lesbian in any way, I'm just not gay myself.
 

FinalGamer

New member
Mar 8, 2009
966
0
0
This'll help the discussion - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_characters_in_video_games - my personal favourite homosexual in games was Trevor from Phantasmagoria 2: A Puzzle of Flesh. He is the kind of guy I would so be great pals with.....and hell, maybe more.

I was REALLY hoping there'd be some male love for male Shepard too, damnit. I hope this will be rectified in the sequel!
 

Wounded Melody

New member
Jan 19, 2009
539
0
0
I want a FF with a love story between 2 male leads. Not just innuendo though, which applies to most of the FF games anyway.
 

FinalGamer

New member
Mar 8, 2009
966
0
0
Terrortree said:
Disgusting. I don't understand WHY anyone would want to add that.
They did it in Jade Empire. Well it was only just relationships and nothing more but still, all for equality.

Oh and I also remembered, Ashton from Star Ocean 2, who MIGHT be gay as the ending with him and Claude implies it when they have a "man-date" but well he IS my fave character of the game.
 
Mar 12, 2009
915
0
0
Homosexuality doesn't bug me in characters unless it's that really annoying stereotype, which is annoying for 2 reasons

1) It's a stereotype

2) The stereotype is so flamboyant and in your face it makes me dislike that person

It's why I dread the next installment of GTA featuring a gay character as all their gay characters have conformed to the stereotype (that Johnny guy you chase on a motorbike for OG Loc in San Andreas, Bernie Crane/Florian Cravic in GTA4)

But if they're sexuality is subtley done so it makes them look comfortable and that they have more important things on their mind than it then I'm all for it
 

Matronadena

New member
Mar 11, 2009
879
0
0
DI7789 said:
Nobody remembers KotOR? Juhani and the female Jedi? (And quite a few more that don't yet come to mind). Also, Fable and Sims 2 (Obviously, they've been mentioned previously but deserve to be mentioned again). I'm not 100% sure, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was a gay sex scene in The Witcher (I'm only able to play about half an hour of that game before my computer craps out). If you've ever read a fanfiction on the internet, you will find that just about every character has mysteriously turned gay. I think Tommy (A character who had a short scene with one of the main characters in which he creeps her out with a tarot card reading) from Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy was gay (I recall there were some hints at it). There are probably more that I missed
I do remember that quite well.. what actually upset me is that LA made them drop that part out from a climax ( pun half intended) as that really was a relationship you had to really work on and build up... where as most others are pretty easy to stumble into by default... It would have been in my opinion one of the most genuine romance options to date.

now with ME, as much as I love how much emotion they tried to put into it, and as much as I liked Liara, she seems to be after my "eternity" almost from the start, and you so much as nod to her as you pass her in a hall and she's yours.. getting Ash " though I was not too fond of her personally" would have been more of a challenge given her personality.

In fable 2 I noticed though that if you flirt enough with a straight character, you can break them down to being bi, or even gay/lesbian over time.

" I do point out on that I have 4 wives " including the countess" and one hubby, just because I wanted kids...who never freaking age! "

again in a recent one, SR2 slipped some npc lady love into it when you do the escort runs...though I was quite heartbroken that when ho-ing there was always a male voice...
 

Gamine

New member
Mar 7, 2009
314
0
0
redjolt said:
At the risk of being universally hated, it sounds a bit too much like a pointless liberal excursion to me. Like in Robocop 2.
Sorry!
Exactly. .no point, except the game is about sex or family or something. .

I heard Vaan (FF12) is gay, how true?
 

Wounded Melody

New member
Jan 19, 2009
539
0
0
(quote button isn't working for me for some reason..)
"I'm all for gay characters, as long as their sexuality isn't their defining feature. Gay is a sexuality, not a type of personality."

What exactly do you mean by that? That they aren't flamboyant, or just that they don't go much beyond mentioning it?
I find that a lot of RPG characters flaunt their *heterosexuality* and if that's ok, why not the other way around?
Would you be upset if FF8 had been a love story between Squall and another male instead of Rinoa?
Just curious...
 

trelloskilos

New member
Mar 11, 2009
112
0
0
keptsimple said:
Florian in GTA4 is gay. Unfortunately, he is depicted as over-the-top flamboyant. He was so over-the-top that it was almost hard to find offensive; but he wasn't very funny either.

Florian was depicted as an over the top homosexual because he had been repressed all of his life, it was pretty much hinted at throughout the entire game that he was acting like that because that's how he felt a gay person WOULD act.
Without knowing about Florian's history, that's quite an assumption, and sadly, my personal experience with gay guys does indicate that there is a minority who have repressed themselves, and later in life, become camp & flamboyant.

(Apologies if that sounded homophobic. It's not intended to be. I am openly gay, and I am in a relationship. Both of us are avid gamers, and I've nver ever been bothered about the sexuality of NPCs, or even main characters.)

The problem with the camp & flamboyant representations is that it doesn't represent the broad scale of diversity, but because camp characters are more memorable and noticeable, they leave more of an impression on straight people, and as a result, become stereotypes.

If developers are going to insist on games with gay characters, I would like to see a more open attempt to diversify rather than just put a guy with a pink cravat & slight lisp in and call themselves liberal game developers.

Perhaps it's most important with RPGs (particularly MMORPGs), and with open ended games which rely on the player being able to impart something of themselves into their character.

Bottom line though....Monkfish pretty much said everything there is to say, and I'm just waffling. :)
 

robinkom

New member
Jan 8, 2009
655
0
0
Abedeus said:
Shepard is a lesbian, if you are playing female.

While the Asari do not consider themselves Female/Male, they do look female. And, well, that makes our Spectre a homosexual.
First I will make clear that I am a straight male to help put my points into perspective.

I tend to actually play female protagonists more if given the choice, mostly out of my admiration for strong female heroes that can be interesting and likable without getting their breasts out. I have no patience for the "rough, bad-ass" under-charismatic male leads that litter so many mainstream titles. It's one-dimensional rubbish for the chauvinist pig demographic who, themselves, imagine they are some kind of faux-macho action hero with a magnetic attraction to danger and skinny blond women outfitted with medicine balls for breasts.

In Mass Effect, I did play as the female Shepard and did pursue the romance dialog with the male NPC (his name escapes me). I saw no problem in doing so, after all, their intent was for a smooth cinematic presentation, right? It was well-written if anything though I couldn't shake the niggling fact that the male NPC's voice actor was the guy who did Carth and female Shepard's actress also did Bastilla, both from Star Wars: KOTOR; I kept waiting for a 2 hour dialog of Wookie growling.

In my second play-through I was the female Shepard again and chose the dialog path with the Asari instead, and honestly, their "love" scene was just creepy as hell with all the psychedelic effects and her coal black eyes. By the end, having the realization that I just made Shepard a Lesbian didn't really bother me at all. It becomes a footnote when compared to the rest of the main plot and her role in the story, besides the fact that neither your nor Llara's dialog for expressing your feelings for each other aren't very well written or characterized.

The problem with Mass Effect is that you cannot have a male/male relationship, but you can have a female/female one. It demonstrates that as far as this stuff is concerned, the mass media is far more comfortable with lesbians than it is with gays - especially when that lesbian relationship culminates in a sex scene that can be validated by the male gaze.
Honestly, I think that is a unfair for any homosexual male players who were unable to pursue a romance arc to their tastes. I thought everyone within the 20-40 age group that works in the game industry were mature adults, I guess I was wrong. I'd have no problem if it were included, this is all optional side-quest material anyway. And even though it's optional, it should still be fair to everyone's preferences.
 

pffh

New member
Oct 10, 2008
774
0
0
Well for most characters you don't know if they're gay or not since their sexuality never comes up in the game. For example how can you tell if say Master Chief or Gordon Freeman are gay or straight? You can't since gay people really don't act any different then straight people.
 

Xan Krieger

Completely insane
Feb 11, 2009
2,918
0
0
pffh said:
Well for most characters you don't know if they're gay or not since their sexuality never comes up in the game. For example how can you tell if say Master Chief or Gordon Freeman are gay or straight? You can't since gay people really don't act any different then straight people.
It's heavily assumed they are straight because they both work alongside a female through parts of the games in their respective series. Besides, let's face it Cortana is one hot piece of computer code.

The only time I think it good when they have gays in games is when they fit the stereotype so well. I love laughing at stereotypes because I know a few gay girls and they act nothing like the stereotype.
 

mooncalf

<Insert Avatar Here>
Jul 3, 2008
1,164
0
0
Who was that noble in Morrowind? I think he was a House Hlaalu, to get his support in your bid to become house leader he expected you to take off your clothes.

El Burro from GTA.

Army Of Two? Okay cheap shot...

Considering the recent articles on how sexuality is (poorly) handled in games, one can expect that it will be even longer before any palatable depictions of homosexuality come about.