Dreiko said:
Prof. Monkeypox said:
Dreiko said:
Prof. Monkeypox said:
Dreiko said:
Prof. Monkeypox said:
The Japanese are rather known for their Xenophobia, so the fact that they refuse to acknowledge Western contributions to gaming could be seen as a symptom of that. Of course, it is interesting that most American productions are so Ameri-centric as to be ludicrous in some intsances, but that's kind of beside the point.
Many Japanese are xenophobic, is that why Western games aren't big there? I dunno. Japanese games are bigger here than American games are there, and you can chock that up to culture clashes, but it doesn't explain why so many Americans love "very Japanese" games.
Americans are a wide variety of people, the ones who tend to like "very Japanese" stuff often don't much like the stuff that actual Japanese folks don't like as well. It's a style, unique, with fans and haters, like most other things. Whether you're Japanese or not, liking Japanese style games is often connected with a bunch of other kind of activities you enjoy and the folks into that generally are not that into the typical "western" style of game.
Yes, and Japan is not a very diverse group, which is probably how the xenophobia maintains to this day. Besides, how does Japan not have a market force of Western loving gamers to match America's love of Japanese games if it's just a matter of taste? There is one, certainly, but it's not nearly as great as the Japan-loving market force in America. Probably this lack of taste for Western sensibilities comes from a lack of exposure to them. I think the idea that Japanese xenophobia might be to blame for lack of acceptance of Western games is not to be dismissed out of hand, as it could be the result of various greater social issues and histories.
America contains a much larger population, more young people in that population and a huge ethnic variety in those people. Japan's people are 99% Japanese. Only 1% are foreigners, that leads to a much more mono-culture which is less prone to be open to experiencing different things.
That, is different to xenophobia.
So the fact that a country is 99% monolithically the same culture precludes xenophobia just because they're not exactly the same thing?
No, I'm not saying Japan is xenophobic because of their population distribution, I am saying that Japan is xenophobic (period) which might be symptomatic of the fact that their lack of cultural exposure (due to the 99% Japanese) prevents them from understanding other cultures. Also, that the fact that they are xenophobic might be an explanation for their dislike of Western games.
The fact that Japanese are xenophobic is a separate issue from population dynamics.
In case you're wondering:
I'm not insulting Japan by saying they're xenophobic anymore than I'm insulting America for being fat and arrogant, or for saying the French are elitist and stuck in the past. These are just cultural things.
*(I am American/French)
But what I said before was that, even non-Japanese people, people in America, also tend to dislike the traditional "western" style of games when they happen to be into the Japanese style, which is also an explanation as to why Japanese people too don't like that style. That explanation being totally without any relation to xenophobia since Americans can't be xenophobic of their own games while they tend to display similar dislike of them as the one Japanese folk do, making the Japanese one too also non-xenophobic due to it's similarity to the American dislike.
Not to be rude, I literally cannot be sure what your trying to say. Rephrase it perhaps.
What I think you mean is that Japan has been known to dislike Western games, and America has also been known to dislike some Western games.
Well, yeah, because some Western games suck, no matter where you are. You seem to be implying that Japanese games are more popular in America as well as more popular in Japan- but that's not true at all. That's like saying that Japanese gamers don't like Japanese games because some Japanese games are terrible.
If a person prefers a Japanese style of game, they will be less likely to enjoy a Western style of game- which is pretty logical as they are quite different, and have differences in mechanics that appeal to different people.
But that's also not the point, the point is that Western cultures are more accepting of Japanese games than the Japanese are of Western games. So the fact that some people in Western cultures prefer Japanese games isn't proving your point, it's contrasting it.
Unless that is your point, in which case, why are you arguing?