If you could take 3 games...

[Thundero13]

1. MineCraft because it could be played for a long time
2. Pokemon Black & White because I could spend my entire life trying to get all 649 pokemon
3. Sims 3 because it goes on forever
and obviously because they're all fun

 

[Mistermixmaster]

Valkyria Chronicles (do I get to play the DLC that I have already bought for the game a long time ago? If not, that's ok, it's still my first choice)

Persona 4.

and... umm... I dunno really. Clannad's Visual Novel? Does that count? I dunno, there isn't a lot of games I like to replay unless I'm in a specific mood.

 

[Kevon Huggins]

Fallout 3 Prototype and minecraft

 

[Death God]

MineCraft

Super Smash Bros Brawl

WoW (I don't like the game but I am sure I could replay it for eternity in terms of re playability)

 

[Sei]

I mostly like RPGs, but they aren't that fun to replay unless there is a few years in between plays. If I were to be playing for eternity it'd have to be a game that could continue to evolve.

The only game that I currently play that would fit the bill would be WoW. If I needed 2 more they would also be MMOs.

 

[Kohake]

I'd probably take the games that have the best mod community. Assuming I can't have mods for my 3 games I would probably stop playing games at all and spend my time with pen & paper games.

 

[Wapox]

Lost Odyssey Xbox 360 4 discs, more than 50 hours on each disc

SmackDown vs RAW 2011 Xbox 360 Never get's old.. I love beating people up with the Undertaker

Warcraft 3 TFT PC I've played it almost every day since it cam out.. and I'm not gonna stop anytime soon...

Those 3!

 

[Dr Jones]

So yeah OP, can we play multiplayer (offline or online?)

I'ma be large here, you will be able to play a game with 1 other person, no more. If the game has online though there will be an infinite amount of players.

 

[ZeroDotZero]

Starcraft 2

I will leave my other slots open, one is reserved for Mass Effect 3, and the other is probably going for WoW.

 

[StormShaun]

Saints Row 3

Mass Effect 3

Battlefield 3.....all 3...bwhaha

 

[Scarim Coral]

I would choose-

Animal crossing

Phantasy Star Online

Guild Wars

 

[Azrael the Cat]

Fallout 2 (much more content than 1), Planescape: Torment (can't beat taking the greatest with you), Deus Ex (massive variety of ways to tackle the objectives on each map; allowing for emergent gameplay provides for greater replayability than a massive sandbox in the long term (as the sandbox game mechanics still only give you one way of doing each task).

 

[aaronobst]

N64 - Perfect Dark (The greatest game ever created)

Elder Scrolls IV Oblivion

Minecraft